BEDFORD — Just before the Bedford County School Board meeting started on Thursday — the meeting at which the board would decide whether or not to close Stewartsville Elementary School — a sign fell off the wall.
It was one of the signs community members hung in the School Administration Office before the meeting to express their support for Stewartsville.
In hindsight, the sign falling was indicative of how the night would go for Staunton River zone parents who were hoping the board would vote to keep the elementary school open.
![]()
A person in the audience holds up a sign reading "Fund Our
School" during the Bedford County School Board meeting in the
School Administration Office in Bedford on Thursday, March 12,
2026.
Matthew Perschall, The News & Advance
About 50 community members, many dressed in green and yellow, attended Thursday’s meeting — either sitting or standing in the boardroom — while others watched the livestream outside.
After hearing concerns from 19 Staunton River community members, the board voted 5-2 to close Stewartsville, with District 2 representative Matthew Holbrook and District 1 representative Jordan Karnes voting against the motion.
The board previously voted against closing Stewartsville in 2024 when it was presented as one of four options to help address the division’s budget shortfall.
“I said it two years ago that I would much rather put the money into our students and our teachers than into bricks when it makes sense,” said Board Chair and District 7 representative Chris Daniels, who introduced the plan. “And this is not an easy decision.”
The board agreed to vote separately on the part of the plan focused on Staunton River zone grade reconfiguration, and approved a motion to begin efforts to obtain mobile units for Goodview Elementary School to increase capacity.
This will allow Staunton River zone fifth-grade students to stay at their elementary schools and eighth-grade students at their middle schools.
“I’m very against closing Stewartsville Elementary School,” said Karnes, who introduced a failed motion to delay the vote until the next school board meeting. “I don't like that idea, but I want to try to find a solution that, if that has to come to pass, that it's still not a burden on my families in my district.”
BCPS Assistant Superintendent of Finance & Operations Randy Hagler said keeping fifth-grade students at Goodview would require three double-wide mobile units.
Based on preliminary inquiries, he said they would cost roughly $810,000 including set-up costs.
Daniels said if the division can’t get the mobile units in time for the start of the 2026-27 school year, it will temporarily proceed with the original reconfiguration plan until the units are complete.
Under that plan, Stewartsville kindergarten through fourth-grade students would attend Goodview, and all fifth-grade students from Stewartsville, Goodview, Huddleston and Moneta Elementary schools would attend Staunton River Middle School. Eighth-grade students would attend Staunton River High School.
Hagler said the positions cut from this decision will be one teacher, two librarians, one principal, one guidance counselor, 2.5 clerical employees, one reading specialist, two paraprofessionals, one nurse and four custodial employees.
He said the decision will save BCPS $1.1 million in yearly operations, and it will address the county’s impending “reversion cliff,” which is state funding tied to the former city of Bedford’s reversion to a town in 2013 that will go away in the 2028-29 budget year.
![]()
Chair Chris Daniels speaks during the Bedford County School
Board meeting in the School Administration Office in Bedford on
Thursday, March 12, 2026.
Matthew Perschall, The News & Advance
“What we are really up against, it is not just, ‘Man, can we make this $1.8 million for next year?’” Daniels said. “It is the $11.7 million shortfall that's going to happen year after year, at a minimum, to our division. If we don't meet that gap, I don't know how we fund 21 schools, I don't know how we fund 20 schools, I don't know how we fund 18 schools, to be honest with you.”
Daniels said this decision wasn’t made in a week.
“It was brought up, but it was brought up two years and a month ago, and we have not stopped talking about it in facility meetings, in other committee meetings and at this board,” he said.
Hagler said the board hasn’t discussed what will happen to Stewartsville, but has three options to consider: keep the building, deem it surplus property, or sell it.
Community concerns
During the public hearing, many community members voiced concerns about the developmental appropriateness of fifth-grade students attending middle school and eighth-grade students attending high school.
![]()
Stewartsville teacher Casey Stanley makes a public comment
against closing Stewartsville Elementary School during the Bedford
County School Board meeting in the School Administration Office on
Thursday, March 12.
Matthew Perschall, The News & Advance
Stewartsville teacher Casey Stanley said moving students into middle school earlier than their peers removes stability during critical development years.
“At a time when schools everywhere are working to address rising student mental health concerns, we should be protecting stability, not removing it,” Stanley said.
After the hearing, division leaders presented more details and addressed concerns on the reconfiguration plan, some of which came from the division’s previous plan to close Stewartsville.
BCPS Deputy Superintendent Karen Woodford said that, under reconfiguration, fifth-grade students would be kept in grade-level teams, separated into one area of the building. She said bus drivers would also be trained to keep fifth-grade students at the front of secondary buses.
![]()
Deputy Superintendent Karen Woodford speaks during the Bedford
County School Board meeting in the School Administration Office on
Thursday.
Matthew Perschall, The News & Advance
Woodford acknowledged families are worried about disruption.
“However, there is research and experience to show that students are highly resilient and capable of adapting successfully when transitions are managed.”
After the board voted, Goodview PTA President Amanda Bryan told The News & Advance that she agrees children are resilient.
“But I don't think they should have to be,” she said. “And I certainly don't think that the adults who are entrusted with their care should be the ones putting them in circumstances where they have to reach for that resilience.”
The community also voiced concern at the unfairness of asking the Staunton River zone to absorb the impact of budget concerns.
“If this change is truly best for our students, then it should be for all students of Bedford County, not just one zone,” Stanley said.
Several community members suggested rezoning the entire division, and Woodford said the board would need at least a year to conduct a rezoning study for the division.
Goodview Elementary School fourth grade student speaks at public hearing against the closure of Stewartsville Elementary School Thursday evening.
Many members of the community expressed frustration that the school board proposed the closure and reconfiguration in the final minutes of its budget work session two weeks ago, and scheduled the public hearing and vote for one week later.
“To gain parental trust, the process must be transparent and well-planned,” Staunton River zone teacher and parent Valerie Staton said. “If you cannot manage the logistics of a meeting, we cannot trust you with the future of our children.”
Parents have been asked to process and respond to the board’s proposal, which Bryan said lacked details, in a matter of days.
Stanley said this is causing families to lose trust in public education.
“When that trust erodes, families begin looking at other options,” she said. “We will likely see more families turning to homeschooling or leaving the system entirely.”
Woodford said the division is not concerned that its Title I funding will be jeopardized, and it will continue its adaptive programs. She said BCPS preschool programs will remain open or be relocated, if needed.
Board members react
Karnes said the school board has damaged the trust of its constituents.
“And I only hope that we can do whatever we can to repair that trust and move forward as a board,” he said.
Holbrook said he received a text from Board of Supervisors District 6 representative Bob Davis that said, “Don’t sell our kids out tonight.”
“Y'all sold them out,” Holbrook said. “So, that's all I got to say.”
District 4 representative Jill Dobson said no one on the board took the decision lightly.
“We have had many conversations, and we want what's in the best interest of all Bedford County students, and that's a fact,” she said.
![]()
Vice-Chairman Kurt Hubach speaks during the Bedford County
School Board meeting in the School Administration Office in
Bedford, Thursday, March 12, 2026. (Matthew Perschall/The News &
Advance)
Matthew Perschall,The News & Advance
Board Vice Chair Kurt Hubach agreed that it was a difficult decision.
“I want to thank everybody for your emails,” he said. “Your passion, your attachment to the Stewartsville community, is loud and clear, and yet, it doesn't solve the fiscal issues.”
District 5 representative Dora Purvis said she didn’t like the fact the board introduced and voted on the plan in a week.
“I wish we would have had a little more time,” she said.
What’s next?
The community urged the school board throughout the evening to work with the Bedford County Board of Supervisors, and Daniels said the school board would meet with them on Friday.
“We are going to be discussing it, and we're going to go into detail of the financial realities that we have, and we want to hear what their financial realities are too,” he said. “We are absolutely going to make the case.”
Daniels said closing Stewartsville will not be the board's last move.
“I think you need to hear that loud and clear,” he said. “We are going to have to look at things in the Forest zone with capacity issues. We might have to look at rezoning, we may have to look at redistricting, we may have to look at, in the Forest zone, going to year-round school in some buildings.”
After the board came out of closed session, it gave consensus on three actions related to overcrowding in the Forest zone.
One was for the division to conduct a study and submit a plan for redistricting students from Westyn Village Apartments, a new development zoned for Forest Elementary School.
The board also agreed to consider the overflow model for new developments in the Forest elementary zone and for students coming from a subdivision off Va. 811 across from New London golf course.
Bryan said although she is grateful for the board’s decision to keep Staunton River fifth- and eighth-grade students in their current configuration, she does not feel that parents’ concerns were heard on Thursday.
“At the end of the day, I think that the school board has broken public trust in a big way,” she said.