Does scaring people work when it comes to health messaging? A communication researcher explains

kAmx? E96 C646?E 7:=> “k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?6E7=:I]4@>^E:E=6^g`adabdfQms@?’E {@@< &Ak^2m[” EH@ 2DEC@?@>6CD =62C? E92E 2 4@>6E :D @? EC24< E@ 4@==:56 H:E9 t2CE9 2?5 56DEC@J 9F>2? 4:G:=:K2E:@?] (96? E96J ECJ E@ D@F?5 E96 2=2C>[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^5@?E\=@@<\FA\9@==JH@@5D\AC:>6C\@?\4=:>2E6\56?:2=\:==FDEC2E6D\d\>JE9D\E92E\7F6=\C6;64E:@?\@7\D4:6?46\`fcaeeQm2== >2??6C @7 @3DE24=6Dk^2m 86E :? E96:C H2J] x? E96 6?5[ H6==[ J@F’== 92G6 E@ H2E49 E96 >@G:6 E@ 7:?5 @FE]k^Am

kAm%96 7:=> :D 7:4E:@?[ @7 4@FCD6[ 3FE E96 D:EF2E:@? :==F>:?2E6D @?6 7246E @7 C62=:EJi (96? A6@A=6 ECJ E@ H2C? @E96CD @7 :>A6?5:?8 52?86C[ DF446DD :D ?@E 8F2C2?E665]k^Am

kAm(2C?:?8 >6DD286D EC2G6= F?56C 2 G2C:6EJ @7 ?2>6D[ :?4=F5:?8 762C 2AA62=D[ E9C62E 2AA62=D 2?5 C:D< 4@>>F?:42E:@?] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D49@=2C]8@@8=6]4@>^4:E2E:@?DnFD6ClGvAg(z|ppppyU2>Aj9=l6?QmpD 2 4@>>F?:42E:@? D4:6?E:DEk^2m H9@ 92D DEF5:65 H2C?:?8 >6DD286D 7@C c_ J62CD[ x’G6 E9@F89E 2 =@E 23@FE E96 BF6DE:@? @7 H96? 762C 2AA62=D 2C6 966565 2?5 H96? E96J 2C6 ?@E – 2 4@?D:56C2E:@? E92E 92D F?5@F3E65=J 366? @? E96 >:?5D @7 >2?J AF3=:4 962=E9 @77:4:2=D E9C@F89@FE E96 r~'xs\`h A2?56>:4]k^Am

k9amr~'xs\`hi p ‘3:@=@8:42= 4@>6E’k^9am

kAmu62C 2AA62=D @3G:@FD=J 2C6?’E =:>:E65 E@ 4@>6ED] (2C?:?8D 23@FE E96 F?H2?E65 4@?D6BF6?46D @7 D>@<:?8[ E6IE:?8 H9:=6 5C:G:?8 2?5 5C:?<:?8 H9:=6 AC68?2?E 42? 36 4@?D:56C65 762C 2AA62=D] $@ 42? 7@@5 C642==D[ 6G24F2E:@? H2C?:?8D 2?5 >6DD286D E92E 6?4@FC286 G244:?2E:@? 7@C E96 7=F[ A@=:@ 2?5 r~'xs\`h]k^Am

kAmqC@25 C6D62C49 =:E6C2EFC6 C6G:6HD[ 42==65 >6E2\2?2=JD6D[ 7:?5 E92E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5@:]@C8^`_]`_g_^abg_ghgd]`hgc]``efgdg`Qm762C 2AA62=D 5@ H@C<k^2m 7@C >@DE A6@A=6 >@DE @7 E96 E:>6]k^Am

kAmp?5 J6E[ 4@?D:56C H96C6 D@4:6EJ 7:?5D :ED6=7 E@52J] u@C E96 A2DE EH@ J62CD[ A6@A=6 E96 H@C=5 @G6C 92G6 366? E@=5 E92E E96J 2C6 :? 52?86C @7 4@?EC24E:?8 2 A@E6?E:2==J 5625=J 5:D62D6 – 2 D@CE @7 3:@=@8:42= 4@>6E – 2?5 E92E 2 G2C:6EJ @7 962=E9 AC@E64E:G6 3692G:@CD[ DF49 2D D@4:2= 5:DE2?4:?8[ >2D<:?8 2?5 G244:?2E:@?[ 42? D2G6 =:G6D] $E:==[ >2?J A6@A=6 7@C8@ D@4:2= 5:DE2?4:?8[ C6;64E >2D<:?8 C64@>>6?52E:@?D 2?5 4@?E:?F6 E@ C67FD6 2 G244:?6 E92E H:== AC@E64E E96>] (9Jnk^Am

kAmk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^7:=6D^cc_bce^@C:8:?2=^7:=6\a_aa_```\aabab\;Jc?_<];A8n:I=:3lC3\`]`]_U2>AjBlcdU2>Aj2FE@l7@C>2EU2>Aj2=ElQ H:5E9lQ`__TQ ^m k6>mkDA2? 4=2DDlQ42AE:@?Qmx? wF?E:?8E@? q6249[ r2=:7][ 25F=ED 2?5 49:=5C6? 2=:<6 56>@?DEC2E65 282:?DE r~'xs\`h G244:?6 >2?52E6D 7@C DEF56?ED]k^DA2?m kDA2? 4=2DDlQ2EEC:3FE:@?Qmk2 4=2DDlQD@FC46Q 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]86EEJ:>286D]4@>^56E2:=^?6HD\A9@E@^A6@A=6\56>@?DEC2E6\282:?DE\4@G:5\`h\G244:?6\>2?52E6D\7@C\?6HD\A9@E@^`abfdacgabn25AA@AFAlECF6Qm#@3J? q64<^pu! G:2 v6EEJ x>286Dk^2mk^DA2?mk^6>mk^Am

k9amw@H 762C 2AA62=D 72:= – 2E E:>6Dk^9am

kAm&?56CDE2?5:?8 H96? 762C 2AA62=D H@C< 2?5 H96? E96J 5@?’E C6BF:C6D D@>6 <?@H=6586 @7 H92E E96J 2C6 2?5 9@H E96J 7F?4E:@?] u62C 2AA62=D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^ADJ4?6E]2A2]@C8^C64@C5^a_`b\bhacb\_`aQm92G6 EH@ 5:DE:?4E A2CEDk^2m] %96 7:CDE A2CE 56D4C:36D E96 52?86C] %96 D64@?5 56D4C:36D 9@H E@ >:E:82E6 E96 52?86C]k^Am

kAmx7 E96J 2C6 H6== 4C27E65[ E96 7:CDE A2CE D42C6D E96 A6@A=6 C646:G:?8 E96 >6DD286 2?5 E96 D64@?5 42=>D E96> 5@H?] pD 2 A6CD@? 962CD @C C625D 2 762C 2AA62= 7C@> 368:??:?8 E@ 6?5[ 762C =@@<D =:<6 2? :?G6CE65 &i xE C:D6D 2?5 E96? :E 72==D]k^Am

kAm#6D62C49 x 92G6 4@?5F4E65 H:E9 >J 4@==628F6D 2E !6?? $E2E6 D9@HD E92E 3@E9 E96 6D42=2E:@? 2?5 56\6D42=2E:@? @7 762C >FDE @44FC k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5@:]@C8^`_]`_g_^_bebffd`]a_`e]``dgc`aQm7@C E96 >6DD286 E@ 36 67764E:G6k^2m] (:E9@FE E96 C:D6 2?5 E96 72== @7 762C[ E96 >6DD286 H:== 72:=] $@ H92E >:89E :?E6C76C6 H:E9 E9:D AC@46DDnk^Am

kAmp 8C62E 562= 9:?86D @? H92E A6@A=6 36=:6G6 23@FE E96 DFAA@D65 E9C62E] x7 E96 AC@3=6> :D ?@E D66? 2D D6C:@FD[ E96C6 :D ?@ C62D@? E@ 36 27C2:5[ ?@ ?665 E@ A2J 2EE6?E:@? E@ E96 C64@>>6?565 D@=FE:@? 2?5 ?@ ?665 E@ AC@E64E @?6D6=7]k^Am

kAmuC@> E96 62C=:6DE 52JD @7 E96 r~'xs\`h A2?56>:4[ D@>6 >6DD286 D@FC46D 5@H?A=2J65 E96 E9C62E] !C6D:56?E %CF>A[ 7@C :?DE2?46[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]7@C36D]4@>^D:E6D^E@>>J366C^a_a_^_h^`_^2==\E96\E:>6D\ECF>A\4@>A2C65\4@G:5\`h\E@\E96\7=F\6G6?\27E6C\96\<?6H\4@G:5\`h\H2D\72C\>@C6\5625=J^nD9leda64fdf7h5aQm4@>A2C65 E96 ?@G6= 4@C@?2G:CFDk^2m E@ 2?@E96C 5:D62D6 E92E D@4:6EJ 92D =62C?65 E@ 4@A6 H:E9] “%9:D :D 2 7=F] %9:D :D =:<6 2 7=F[” %CF>A D2:5] $E2E6>6?ED @7 E9:D D@CE 4@>AC@>:D65 677@CED E@ 4@?G6J E96 ECF6 C:D<D @7 r~'xs\`h]k^Am

kAmp?5 6G6? 2 D6C:@FD E9C62E >FDE 36 D66? 2D C6=6G2?E @C :E :D F?=:<6=J E@ 6G@<6 DEC@?8 6>@E:@?] t2C=J :? E96 A2?56>:4[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5@:]@C8^`_]`__`^;2>2]a_a_]adbg`QmD@>6 2C62Dk^2m H6C6 9:E 92C5 3J E96 G:CFD H9:=6 @E96CD 6IA6C:6?465 C6=2E:G6=J =@H :?764E:@? C2E6D] !6@A=6 =:G:?8 :? E9@D6 =@H\42D6=@25 2C62D @7E6? 925 @?=J :?5:C64E :?7@C>2E:@? 23@FE E96 A2?56>:4[ @7E6? E9C@F89 D@4:2= >65:2] p?5 D@4:2= >65:2 4@?E2:?65 2 8C62E 562= @7 >:D:?7@C>2E:@?]k^Am

kAm$EC:<:?8=J[ ;FDE `a A6@A=6 H6C6 C6DA@?D:3=6 7@C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?AC]@C8^a_a`^_d^`b^hhedf_gdd^5:D:?7@C>2E:@?\5@K6?\E6DE\72463@@<D\EH:EE6CD\23:=:EJ\E@\4FC3\G244:?6\9@2I6DQmEH@\E9:C5D @7 E96 >:D:?7@C>2E:@?k^2m 23@FE G244:?6D @? D@4:2= >65:2 A=2E7@C>D DF49 2D %H:EE6C 2?5 u2463@@<] y@D6A9 |6C4@=2[ 2? @DE6@A2E9:4 A9JD:4:2? H:E9 b]e >:==:@? 7@==@H6CD[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4@F?E6C92E6]4@>^5:D:?7@C>2E:@?5@K6?Qm?@E@C:@FD=J 2?5 6CC@?6@FD=J DE2E65k^2mi “%96 D2>6 ?F>36C @7 A6@A=6 5:65 :? a_a_ E92E[ @? 2G6C286[ 92G6 5:65 :? AC6G:@FD J62CD] %9:D D:>A=J H@F=5?’E 36 E96 42D6 :7 H6 925 2 =6E92= A2?56>:4]” %9:D 3=2?<6E 56?:2= @7 E96 G:CFD’D ECF6 :>A24E 2==@H65 2 8C62E >2?J A6@A=6 E@ 4@?4=F56 E92E E96 A2?56>:4 H2D?’E 2 AC@3=6> 7@C E96> @C 7@C 2?J@?6 6=D6]k^Am

kAm%96? E96C6’D E96 BF6DE:@? @7 H92E 42? 36 5@?6 23@FE E96 E9C62E]k^Am

kAmw62=E9 6IA6CED >2:?E2:? – 32D65 @? 2 G2DE 2>@F?E @7 52E2 2?5 D4:6?E:7:4 6G:56?46 – E92E r~'xs\`h G244:?6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]454]8@G^4@C@?2G:CFD^a_`h\?4@G^G244:?6D^67764E:G6?6DD^:?56I]9E>=Qm2C6 9:89=J 67764E:G6k^2m] (96? :?5:G:5F2=D 36=:6G6 E96 C6>65J :D 67764E:G6[ 762C :D 5:>:?:D965 2?5 E96 =:<6=:9@@5 @7 24E:@? :D 6?92?465] qFE 36=:67D 23@FE E96 G244:?6D’ 67764E:G6?6DD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5@:]@C8^`_]`_`e^;]G244:?6]a_a`]_f]_deQm92G6 366? H62<6?65k^2m 3J 4=2:>D E92E E96 G244:?6 :D E@@ ?6H 2?5 F?AC@G6? @C E92E :ED AC@5F4E:@? H2D CFD965]k^Am

kAm{2DE[ 2 <6J 4@?D:56C2E:@? :D H96E96C A6@A=6 42? 24EF2==J 249:6G6 E96 D@=FE:@?] $@4:2= 5:DE2?4:?8 C6BF:C65 A:G@E:?8 E@ C6>@E6 H@C< 2?5 D49@@=[ A=24:?8 2 9F86 3FC56? @? 72>:=:6D E92E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]>4<:?D6J]4@>^762EFC65\:?D:89ED^7FEFC6\@7\H@C<^4@G:5\`h\2?5\86?56C\6BF2=:EJ\4@F?E6C:?8\E96\C68C6DD:G6\67764EDQm76== 5:DAC@A@CE:@?2E6=J @? H@>6?k^2m] |62?H9:=6[ 9:89\BF2=:EJ >2D<D H6C6 :?:E:2==J 6IA6?D:G6 2?5 492==6?8:?8 E@ =@42E6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?JE:>6D]4@>^a_a`^``^b_^962=E9^4@G:5\>2D<D\4@F?E6C76:E\72<6]9E>=Qm:? 2 D62 @7 4@F?E6C76:EDk^2m]k^Am

kAmyFDE 2 J62C 28@[ :? 62C=J a_a`[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?AC]@C8^a_a`^_a^_g^hedd`deb`^H9J\:D\:E\D@\92C5\E@\7:8FC6\@FE\H96C6\E@\86E\G244:?2E65\7@C\4@G:5\`hQmG244:?6D H6C6 F?2G2:=23=6k^2m :? >2?J =@42E:@?D] p?5 ?@H[ 27E6C ?2G:82E:?8 ?62C=J EH@ J62CD @7 492==6?86D :? 252AE:?8 C64@>>6?565 D@=FE:@?D[ E96C6 :D 2 C62= 52?86C E92E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2AAD]H9@]:?E^:C:D^3:EDEC62>^92?5=6^`_eed^bbdga_^(w~\t&#~\a_a_\``e_\c_h_e\ddbh_\6?8]A57QmA2?56>:4 72E:8F6k^2m H:== C65F46 >@E:G2E:@? E@ 2596C6 E@ D276EJ 8F:56=:?6D]k^Am

k9am&?56C>:?:?8 E96 >6DD6?86Ck^9am

kAmu62C 2AA62=D 42? 2=D@ 36 E9H2CE65 :? >@C6 86?6C2= H2JD] u@C :?DE2?46[ 3J 2EEC:3FE:?8 ?672C:@FD >@E:G6D E@ E96 8@G6C?>6?E 2?5 AF3=:4 962=E9 @77:4:2=D[ E9@D6 H9@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^ada7a655\`4g3\ch7d\h33a\43df33cf6c32]7:=6DFDC]4@>^F85^7c5h3h03f4654_ddbe_cfa_3f`bf7geebbee66d]A57QmDAC625 >:D:?7@C>2E:@?k^2m 2?5 4@?DA:C24J E96@C:6D 42? 42FD6 @E96CD E@ 5:D4@F?E 2?J 2?5 2== :?7@C>2E:@? 4@>:?8 7C@> E9@D6 D@FC46D]k^Am

kAmpD x ?@E65 23@G6[ C6D62C49 D9@HD E92E 762C 2AA62=D 2C6 A6CDF2D:G6 7@C >@DE @7 E96 A6@A=6 >@DE @7 E96 E:>6] w@H6G6C[ E96 DEF5:6D F?56C=J:?8 E92E 4@?4=FD:@? 2C6 AC:>2C:=J 6IA6C:>6?ED :? H9:49 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5@:]@C8^`_]`_bf^2__bhfahQm762C 2AA62=D 2C6 4@>A2C65k^2m H:E9 6:E96C D@>6 H62< >6DD286 @C ?@ >6DD286 2E 2==] x? @E96C H@C5D[ E96D6 4@>A2C:D@?D 5@ ?@E 2E 2== C6D6>3=6 E96 C62=:EJ DFCC@F?5:?8 r~'xs\`h]k^Am

kAm!C@\G244:?6 >6DD28:?8 :D E2<:?8 A=246 :? 2 9:89=J 4@>A6E:E:G6 >6DD286 6?G:C@?>6?E – @?6 E92E :?G@=G6D 24E:G6 677@CED E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^ada7a655\`4g3\ch7d\h33a\43df33cf6c32]7:=6DFDC]4@>^F85^7c5h3h03f4654_ddbe_cfa_3f`bf7geebbee66d]A57QmF?56C>:?6 AF3=:4 962=E9 25G@424Jk^2m] %96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]H2D9:?8E@?A@DE]4@>^962=E9^a_aa^_`^_f^H2=6?D<J\454\4@?7FD:?8\>6DD28:?8^Qm:?4@?D:DE6?E 2?5 4@?EC25:4E@CJ >6DD28:?8k^2m AC@5F465 3J 962=E9 286?4:6D DF49 2D E96 r6?E6CD 7@C s:D62D6 r@?EC@= 2?5 !C6G6?E:@? 92D 52>2865 E96 67764E:G6?6DD @7 762C 2AA62=D] %96 724E E92E D4:6?E:7:4 <?@H=6586 6G@=G6D 2?5 2=H2JD A@DD6DD6D 2 568C66 @7 F?46CE2:?EJ 6IA=2:?D H9J 962=E9 286?4:6D 492?865 – 2?5 4@?E:?F6 E@ 492?86 – E96:C >6DD28:?8] #68C6EE23=J[ E9:D :?4@?D:DE6?4J 2=D@ F?56C4FED E96 :>A24E @7 962=E9 >6DD28:?8 :? 2 AF3=:4 E92E H2?ED D:>A=6[ 4@?D:DE6?E 2?DH6CD]k^Am

kAmp?5 ;FDE 2D :? “s@?’E {@@< &A[” G2C:@FD 8C@FAD 2?5 :?5:G:5F2=D 92G6 AC:@C:E:K65 E96:C @H? D9@CE\E6C> 82:?D @G6C 2 86?F:?6 8=@32= 52?86C] %9@D6 4@==64E:G6 677@CED 92G6 =67E =2C86 DH2E9D @7 E96 A@AF=2E:@? F?4@?46C?65 @C 56>@E:G2E65 23@FE 2 86?F:?6 8=@32= E9C62E] %9:D 96=AD E@ 6IA=2:? H9J E96 &]$] 92D >2?J >@C6 562E9D 7C@> r~'xs\`h E92? 5@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?JE:>6D]4@>^:?E6C24E:G6^a_aa^_a^_`^D4:6?46^4@G:5\562E9D\F?:E65\DE2E6D]9E>=Qm@E96C H62=E9J ?2E:@?Dk^2m] %96 A2C2==6=D 36EH66? 4:?6>2 2?5 C62=:EJ 2C6 >@C6 E92? 2 =:EE=6 7C:89E6?:?8]k^Am

kAm000k^Am

kAmk6>m{:<6 H92E J@F’G6 C625n (2?E >@C6nk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^>6>36CD6CG:46D]E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^?6HD=6EE6CD^nD@FC46l:?=:?6\=:<6E9:DQm$:8? FA 7@C %96 r@?G6CD2E:@?’D 52:=J ?6HD=6EE6Ck^2m]k^Am

kAmk6>mkDA2?my2>6D s:==2C5 5@6D ?@E H@C< 7@C[ 4@?DF=E[ @H? D92C6D :? @C C646:G6 7F?5:?8 7C@> 2?J 4@>A2?J @C @C82?:K2E:@? E92E H@F=5 36?67:E 7C@> E9:D 2CE:4=6[ 2?5 92D 5:D4=@D65 ?@ C6=6G2?E 277:=:2E:@?D 36J@?5 E96:C 24256>:4 2AA@:?E>6?E]k^DA2?mk^6>mk^Am

kAmk6>mkDA2?m000k^DA2?mk^6>mk^Am