Court fight over Buffalo's redistricting draws sharp exchanges from rival experts

kAm~FC r:EJ p4E:@? qF772=@[ 2 A@=:E:42= 24E:@? 8C@FA[ E62>65 H:E9 ?:?6 G@E6CD :? ~4E@36C E@ DF6 4:EJ @77:4:2=D @G6C E96 C65:DEC:4E:?8[ D2J:?8 E96J 5:5 ?@E E2<6 :?E@ 244@F?E ?6:893@C9@@5D[ AC@>@E6 C24:2= 72:C?6DD @C 7@==@H E96 32D:4 C65:DEC:4E:?8 C6BF:C6>6?ED D6E 3J DE2E6 =2H 2?5 E96 4:EJ 492CE6C]k^Am

kAm~? 3692=7 @7 ~FC r:EJ p4E:@? qF772=@[ #FDD6== (62G6C[ 2 86@8C2A96C 2?5 BF2?E:E2E:G6 D@4:2= D4:6?E:DE H:E9 25G2?465 568C66D :? 86@8C2A9J 2?5 64@?@>:4D 7C@> E96 &?:G6CD:EJ 2E qF772=@[ C6DA@?565 E@ E96 4@?4=FD:@?D >256 3J EH@ 6IA6CED 9:C65 3J E96 4:EJi |:4926= y] q2C36C[ 2? 2DD@4:2E6 A@=:E:42= D4:6?46 AC@76DD@C 2E qC:892> *@F?8 &?:G6CD:EJ[ 2?5 |:4926= !] |4s@?2=5[ 2 A@=:E:42= D4:6?46 AC@76DD@C 2E E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 u=@C:52]k^Am

kAm(62G6CVD C6A@CE 42==65 q2C36CVD 2?2=JD6D Q7=2H65 7C@> E96 @FED6EQ 2?5 QDFA6C7=F@FD]Qk^Am

kAm(92EVD >@C6[ (62G6C 244FD65 |4s@?2=5 @7 >2<:?8 2 QD42C6 BF@E6Q E92E QC2:D6D BF6DE:@?D 23@FE H96E96C 9:D 7:?2?4:2= C6=2E:@?D9:A E@ E96 C6DA@?56?ED 27764ED 9:D ;F58>6?E]Qk^Am

kAm%96 4:EJVD 6IA6CED 9FC=65 E96:C @H? 4C:E:4:D>D]k^Am

kAm(62G6C QAC@G:56D ?@ C:8@C@FD 2?2=JD:DQ @7 E96 C6E6?E:@? @7 5:DEC:4E 4@C6D :? E96 2AAC@G65 >2A[ q2C36C D2:5 :? 9:D C6A@CE] p?5 (62G6C FD65 2? 288C682E6 :?56I @7 >F=E:A=6 5:776C6?E >62DFC6D @? E96 4@>A24E?6DD @7 E96 86@8C2A9:4 2C62D @7 E96 G@E:?8 5:DEC:4ED QE92E 92D ?@ :?E6CAC6E23=6 >62?:?8]Qk^Am

kAm|4s@?2=5 D2:5 96 7@F?5 (62G6CVD @A:?:@?D QF?A6CDF2D:G6 2?5 :?4@>A=6E6]Qk^Am

kAm%96 4:EJVD =2HJ6CD 2=D@ E2C86E65 (62G6C :? :ED 4@FCE A2A6CD[ FC8:?8 $E2E6 $FAC6>6 r@FCE yFDE:46 %:>@E9J (2=<6C E@ C6;64E 9:D C6A@CE]k^Am

kAmQsC] (62G6C :D 2? 25G@42E6[ ?@E 2 ?6FEC2= 6IA6CE[Q 244@C5:?8 E@ 2 7:=:?8 3J 2EE@C?6J rC2:8 #] qF4<: @7 E96 !9:==:AD {JE=6 =2H 7:C>[ 9:C65 3J E96 4:EJ E@ 5676?5 282:?DE E96 =2HDF:E] k^Am

kAm%96 A@=:E:42= 24E:@? 8C@FA 324<65 2 >2A E92E 2>@?8 @E96C 492?86D 42==65 7@C 6=:>:?2E:?8 E96 u:==>@C6 s:DEC:4E 2?5 :?4C62D:?8 E96 D:K6 @7 E96 t==:4@EE s:DEC:4E[ H9:=6 4C62E:?8 2 ?6H t=>H@@5\p==6?E@H? s:DEC:4E]k^Am

kAm(62G6C’D 3:2D E@H2C5 ~FC r:EJ p4E:@? qF772=@ 6IE6?5D 36J@?5 :ED AC676CC65 C65:DEC:4E:?8 >2A E@ E96 @C82?:K2E:@?VD @G6C2== A@=:E:42= 286?52[ 2?5 E92E QE2:?ED 9:D 2?2=JD:D[Q 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 4:EJVD 4@FCE 7:=:?8]k^Am

kAm%9@D6 =625:?8 ~FC r:EJ p4E:@? qF772=@ @C82?:K65 G@=F?E66CD 2?5 EFC?65 @FE G@E6CD E@ AC@A6= x?5:2 (2=E@? E@ 2 DFCAC:D:?8 >2J@C2= AC:>2CJ H:? @G6C qC@H? =2DE J62C[ 2?5 D96 92D 366? 2 =625:?8 G@:46 :? ~FC r:EJ p4E:@? qF772=@[ DE2?5:?8 2>@?8 E96 >6>36CD H9@ 56>@?DEC2E65[ 492?E65 2?5 A24<65 r@>>@? r@F?4:= 492>36CD @AA@D:?8 E96 2AAC@G65 r@>>@? r@F?4:= 5:DEC:4E 3@F?52C:6D E96J 566>65 86CCJ>2?56C65]k^Am

kAm(62G6C 92D HC:EE6? 2CE:4=6D E92E Q65:E@C:2=:K6 6IE6?D:G6=J :? 72G@C @7 |D] (2=E@? 2?5 282:?DE |2J@C qC@H?[Q 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 7:=:?8[ 4:E:?8 @?6 2CE:4=6 E92E D2:5 E96 >2J@CVD Q7:CDE AC:@C:EJ :D E96 @H?:?8 4=2DDQ H9:=6 56D4C:3:?8 (2=E@? 2? “25G@42E6 7@C @C5:?2CJ A6@A=6]Qk^Am

kAmQsC] (62G6C 92D 6G6CJ C:89E E@ DFAA@CE 2?J A@=:E:42= 42?5:52E6D 96 49@@D6D[Q 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 4@FCE 7:=:?8] QqFE 2?J DF886DE:@? E92E sC] (62G6C :D 2 ?6FEC2= 6IA6CE :D D:>A=J 72=D6]Qk^Am

kAmp52> q@;2<[ @?6 @7 E96 2EE@C?6JD C6AC6D6?E:?8 E9@D6 DF:?8 E96 4:EJ[ D2:5 96 :D 5:D2AA@:?E65 E96 4:EJ E@@< DF49 2 E24E:4 282:?DE (62G6C[ H9@ =:G6D :? E96 %@H? @7 w@==2?5 2?5 :D 5:C64E@C @7 C6D62C49 2E E96 r@C?6== $49@@= @7 x?5FDEC:2= 2?5 {23@C #6=2E:@?D qF772=@ r@\{23] k^Am

kAm“sC] #FDD6== (62G6C :D 2 G6CJ C6DA64E65 86@8C2A96C E@ E96 A@:?E H96C6 96 H2D @? E96 4:E:K6?D 4@>>:DD:@? `_ J62CD 28@ H96? E96J 5C6H E9@D6 >2AD 2E E92E E:>6[ 2?5 E96 :562 E92E 96 5@6D?’E <?@H H92E 96’D E2=<:?8 23@FE :D =2F8923=6 @? :ED 7246[” q@;2< D2:5]k^Am

kAmkDEC@?8mr@FCE 492==6?86 @G6C AC@465FC6 k^DEC@?8mk^Am

kAm%96 4CFI @7 (62G6CVD C6A=J E@ E96 4@FCE 23@FE E96 4:EJ 6IA6CED :D E92E E96J 5:5 ?@E 7@4FD @? 9@H E96 4:EJ H6?E 23@FE C65:DEC:4E:?8] k^Am

kAmw@H E96 25@AE65 C65:DEC:4E:?8 A=2? 4@>A2C65 E@ q2C36CVD 9JA@E96E:42= D6E @7 `__[___ A@DD:3=6 5:DEC:4E:?8 A=2?D :D ?@E C6=6G2?E E@ H96E96C E96 4:EJ 7@==@H65 E96 =2H :? C65:DEC:4E:?8] q2C36C 6?82865 Q:? DFA6C7=F@FD 2?5 :CC6=6G2?E 24256>:4 6I6C4:D6D[Q (62G6C D2:5]k^Am

kAm“%9:D :D 23@FE AC@465FC6[Q q@;2< D2:5 @7 E96 =682= 492==6?86] QxE’D 23@FE AC@46DD @G6C DF3DE2?46] %96J 4@?E:?F6 E@ 7@4FD @? E96 DF3DE2?46[ 3FE H6 ?6G6C C62==J 3C@F89E E92E FA] (6 2C6 D2J:?8 J@F 5:5?’E 5@ :E AC@A6C=J[ 3J E96 3@@<]”k^Am

kAm%96 :DDF6D :? E96 4@FCE AC@4665:?8[ (62G6C D2:5 :? 9:D C6A@CE[ 2C6 H96E96C E96 4:EJ 72:=65 E@ A6C7@C> :ED 5FEJ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 =2Hj H96E96C :E AC@466565 H:E9:? :ED ;FC:D5:4E:@?j H96E96C :ED 564:D:@? H2D >256 :? G:@=2E:@? @7 =2H7F= AC@465FC6[ H2D 2C3:EC2CJ 2?5 42AC:4:@FD @C 2? 23FD6 @7 5:D4C6E:@?j 2?5 H96E96C E96 564:D:@? H2D >256 2D 2 C6DF=E @7 2 962C:?8 96=5[ 2E H9:49 6G:56?46 H2D E2<6? @? E96 C64@C5[ DFAA@CE:?8 E96 564:D:@?]k^Am

kAmQx? E9:D 4@?E6IE[ sC] q2C36CVD 2?2=JD6D 2C6 7=2H65 7C@> E96 @FED6E[Q (62G6C D2:5 :? 2? 277:52G:E] Q%96J 2C6 ?@E 4@?DECF4E65 E@ 2?DH6C E96 BF6DE:@?D F?56C 6I2>:?2E:@? :? E9:D AC@4665:?8]Qk^Am

kAmx?DE625[ q2C36C @776C65 2 4@>AFE6C\D:>F=2E65 A@CE7@=:@ @7 `__[___ 5:DEC:4E:?8 A=2?D 7@C qF772=@[ H:E9 6249 A=2? 4@?E2:?:?8 ?:?6 5:DEC:4ED] q2C36C DF886DED E9:D D6E @7 `__[___ 9JA@E96E:42= 5:DEC:4E A=2?D :D E96 AC@A6C D6E @7 >2AD 7@C 4@>A2C:D@?[ (62G6C D2:5]k^Am

kAmw6 4@>AFE65 G2C:@FD DE2?52C5D :? 9:D D:>F=2E65 A=2?D E@ 4@>A2C6 E@ E96 4:EJVD 2AAC@G65 >2A]k^Am

kAmQ%96D6 2?2=JD6D 4@?D:DE6?E=J =625 9:> E@ A@CEC2J 9:D 4=:6?EDV 6?24E65 >2A :? 72G@C23=6 =:89E[Q (62G6C D2:5] QsC] q2C36CVD 2AA2C6?E 4@?7FD:@? @G6C E96 5:DE:?4E:@? 36EH66? 2? pCE:4=6 fg AC@4665:?8 2?5 =682= 492==6?86D E92E 2C6 3C@F89E F?56C 7656C2= @C DE2E6 C65:DEC:4E:?8 =2HD =625D 9:> E@ 72F=EJ 4@?4=FD:@?D]Qk^Am

kAm(62G6C D2:5 |4s@?2=5 >256 2 >:D=625:?8 DE2E6>6?E 23@FE 9:>[ 2DD6CE:?8 E92E (62G6C 2C8F65 E96 C65:DEC:4E:?8 4@>>:DD:@? D9@F=5 92G6 25@AE65 DF3>:EE65 A=2?D H:E9 =@H6C A@AF=2E:@? 56G:2E:@?D]k^Am

kAmQ}@H96C6 :? >J C6A@CE 5@ x @776C DF49 2? 2C8F>6?E[Q (62G6C D2:5 :? 2? 277:52G:E] Q%96C6 H6C6 ?@ @E96C A=2?D DF3>:EE65 E@ E96 4@>>:DD:@? 5F6 E@ E96 4@>>:DD:@?VD 72:=FC6 E@ 7@==@H =2HD :? E96 492CE6C E92E C6=2E6 E@ C6BF:C6>6?ED 7@C @A6??6DD 2?5 EC2?DA2C6?4J :? E96 C65:DEC:4E:?8 AC@46DD] p44@C5:?8=J[ :E :D :>A@DD:3=6 7@C >6 @C 2?J@?6 6=D6 E@ >2<6 2? 2C8F>6?E E92E E96 4@>>:DD:@? D9@F=5 92G6 25@AE65 A=2?D E92E 5:5 ?@E J6E 6I:DE]Qk^Am

kAm(62G6C 25565i QsC] |4s@?2=5VD H:==:?8?6DD E@ :?G6?E 2? 2C8F>6?E 2?5 2EEC:3FE6 :E E@ >6 – E96 ?@?6I:DE6?46 @7 H9:49 42? 36 62D:=J G6C:7:65 3J 2?J@?6 H9@ E2<6D E:>6 E@ C6G:6H >2:?DEC62> C6A@CE:?8 @? E96 AC@46DD 2?5 E96 5@4F>6?ED 4@?E2:?65 :? E96 A6E:E:@? @7 E9:D AC@4665:?8 – :D BF:E6 EC@F3=:?8]Qk^Am

kAmVkDEC@?8mp 72:C AC@46DDVk^DEC@?8mk^Am

kAm%96 4:EJVD =2HJ6CD D2J E9@D6 DF:?8 ;FDE 5@?’E =:<6 E96 @FE4@>6] %96 r@>>@? r@F?4:=[ |2J@C qJC@? qC@H? 2?5 E96 r:E:K6?D p5G:D@CJ r@>>:DD:@? @? #62AA@CE:@?>6?E – ?2>65 2D 5676?52?ED :? E96 =682= 492==6?86 2=@?8 H:E9 E96 tC:6 r@F?EJ q@2C5 @7 t=64E:@?D – >6E E96:C @3=:82E:@? E@ 6?24E 2 >2A E92E 4@>A=:6D H:E9 E96 =2H[ E9C@F89 2 72:C AC@46DD E92E 2==@H65 qF772=@’D C6D:56?ED E@ 6IAC6DD E96:C G:6HD[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 4:EJVD 4@FCE 7:=:?8]k^Am

kAmQ!6E:E:@?6CD >2J 36 5:DA=62D65 H:E9 E96 C6DF=E[ 3FE E96:C 5:DA=62DFC6 :D ?@ 32D:D E@ @G6CCF=6 E96 A6@A=6’D 6=64E65 C6AC6D6?E2E:G6D[Q 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 7:=:?8] Q%96 A6E:E:@? D9@F=5 36 5:D>:DD65]”k^Am

kAmp 564:D:@? :D 6IA64E65 :? E96 4@>:?8 H66<D]k^Am

kAm“x? =2C86 A2CE … H6 4@?E:?F6 E@ 7:?5 5:D4C6A2?4:6D 36EH66? H92E E96J 4=2:> :? E96:C 7:=:?8D 2?5 H92E E96 ECFE9 24EF2==J :D[” q@;2< D2:5 2E 2 C646?E AC6DD 4@?76C6?46]k^Am

kAmu@C :?DE2?46[ 4:EJ @77:4:2=D 96=5 AF3=:4 >66E:?8D[ 3FE 96 D2:5 E96J E96J 5:5?’E AC@G:56 AC@A6C AF3=:4 ?@E:46]k^Am

kAm“r@?EC25:4E:@?D 4@?E:?F6 E@ 2C:D6 @G6C 2?5 @G6C 2?5 @G6C 282:?[ 2?5 E96 AC@3=6> H:E9 E92E … E96 AC@46DD 92D ?@E 366? 7@==@H65[” q@;2< D2:5] “(6 2C6 56>2?5:?8 :E’D 5@?6 AC@A6C=J]”k^Am

kAm%96 4:EJ 564=:?65 4@>>6?E[ 4:E:?8 :ED A@=:4J @7 ?@E 4@>>6?E:?8 @? A6?5:?8 =:E:82E:@?]k^Am

kAmqJ =2H[ E96 4:EJ >FDE C65C2H :ED 4@F?4:=>2?:4 5:DEC:4E 3@F?52C:6D 6G6CJ 564256 E@ C67=64E A@AF=2E:@? 492?86D :? E96 4:EJ] t249 5:DEC:4E >FDE 36 2AAC@I:>2E6=J 6BF2= :? A@AF=2E:@?]k^Am

kAm%9@D6 DF:?8 E96 4:EJ 92G6 2D<65 E96 ;F586 E@ 2??F= E96 C65:DEC:4E:?8 >2A E92E qC@H? D:8?65 :?E@ =2H @? pF8] `d 2?5 2==@H 7@C 2? 2=E6C?2E6 D6E @7 5:DEC:4E 3@F?52C:6D E@ 36 4C62E65 7C@> 2 72:C6C AC@46DD]k^Am

kAmx? 2 s64] a 7:=:?8[ E96 4:EJ 4@?E6?565 E96 4:E:K6?D 4@>>:DD:@? :D ?@E DF3;64E E@ @A6? >66E:?8D =2H]k^Am

kAmx? =682= 5@4F>6?ED[ E96 4:EJ D2:5 E9@D6 369:?5 E96 =2HDF:E QC646:G65 6G6CJ @AA@CEF?:EJ E@ A2CE:4:A2E6 :? E96 C65:DEC:4E:?8 AC@46DD] p?5 E96J 5:5] %96J 6IAC6DD65 E96:C G:6HD[ =@F5 2?5 4=62C[ 2E H6==\2EE6?565 AF3=:4 962C:?8D 2?5 >66E:?8D 9@DE65 3J E96 r@>>@? r@F?4:= 2?5 >2J@C]”k^Am

kAmx? 2 7:=:?8 %9FCD52J[ $E6A92?:6 p] p52>D[ 2 =2HJ6C 7@C E9@D6 DF:?8 E96 4:EJ[ 4C:E:4:K65 E96 4:EJVD DE2?46 E92E E96 C65:DEC:4E:?8 4@>>:DD:@? H2D?VE DF3;64E E@ E96 @A6? >66E:?8D =2H]k^Am

kAmQ%96 4:EJ C6DA@?56?EDV A@D:E:@? @? E9:D >2EE6C :D DE2886C:?8i %96 4@>>:DD:@? 6>A@H6C65 3J E96 >2J@C 2?5 r@>>@? r@F?4:=[ 7C@> H9:49 E96 86?6C2E:G6 H@C< @7 E96 >2AD 2?5 @G6C2== =68:D=2E:G6 C6AC6D6?E2E:@? @7 6G6CJ C6D:56?E :? E96 4:EJ >FDE DAC:?8[ 2?5 2 C6BF:C65 DE6A :? E96 C62AA@CE:@?>6?E AC@46DD[ :D ?@E E@ 36 @A6? E@ E96 AF3=:4] %9:D A@D:E:@? :D HC@?8[Q p52>D HC@E6 :? E96 7:=:?8]k^Am