Once globally preeminent, US universities are sliding into decline

kAm%96 ?2E:@? H2D 5:DEC24E65 3J @E96C E9:?8D H96? 2 BF:6E H2C?:?8 D@F?565i $FAA@CE H2D 5:>:?:D9:?8 7@C p>6C:42? 24256>:4 C6D62C49 E92E 925 =65 E@ 3C62<E9C@F89D 2?5 :??@G2E:@?]k^Am

kAm%92E 72>:=:2C\D@F?5:?8 H@CCJ 42>6 ?@E E9:D J62C[ 3FE ?62C E96 6?5 @7 (@C=5 (2C xx[ :? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A:]:?7?]:E^O8:@C8:@^x}u}^b|^$4:6?46E96t?5=6DDuC@?E:6C]A57Qm2 A:G@E2= 8@G6C?>6?E DEF5Jk^2m 3J E96 H2CE:>6 ~77:46 @7 $4:6?E:7:4 #6D62C49 2?5 s6G6=@A>6?E] k^Am

kAm%96 C6DA@?D6 E96?i :?7FD:@?D @7 8@G6C?>6?E 42D9 E92E H@F=5 AC@A6= E96 &]$] 9:896C 65F42E:@? DJDE6> :?E@ :?E6C?2E:@?2= AC66>:?6?46 @G6C E96 DF3D6BF6?E 564256D]k^Am

kAmp>6C:42? 4@==686D 2?5 F?:G6CD:E:6D C@D6 E@ E96 C2?<D @7 E96 36DE :? E96 H@C=5] %96J 2EEC24E65 E@A D49@=2CD H9@ H@? 2 5:DAC@A@CE:@?2E6 ?F>36C @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^5:86DE^a_a`_d^6IA=2:?:?8\9:DE@C:42=\C:D6\FD\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6DnA286l`U2>AjA6C!286ld_9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^5:86DE^a_a`_d^6IA=2:?:?8\9:DE@C:42=\C:D6\FD\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6DnA286Tbs`U2>AjA6C!286ld_9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^5:86DE^a_a`_d^6IA=2:?:?8\9:DE@C:42=\C:D6\FD\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6DnA286Tbs`U2>AjA6C!286ld_9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^5:86DE^a_a`_d^6IA=2:?:?8\9:DE@C:42=\C:D6\FD\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6DnA286Tbs`U2>AjA6C!286ld_9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^5:86DE^a_a`_d^6IA=2:?:?8\9:DE@C:42=\C:D6\FD\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6DnA286Tbs`U2>AjA6C!286ld_9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^5:86DE^a_a`_d^6IA=2:?:?8\9:DE@C:42=\C:D6\FD\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6DnA286Tbs`U2>AjA6C!286ld_9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^5:86DE^a_a`_d^6IA=2:?:?8\9:DE@C:42=\C:D6\FD\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6DnA286Tbs`U2>AjA6C!286ld_Qm}@36= !C:K6Dk^2m] %96J 96=A65 5C:G6 E96 :??@G2E:@? 64@?@>J] pD EC256 567:4:ED 36D6E @E96C :?5FDEC:6D[ 65F42E:@? 3642>6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]EC256]8@G^C6D62C49\65F42E:@?\6IA@CEDQmE96 D:IE9\=2C86DE &]$] D6CG:46D 6IA@CEk^2m] pE E96:C A62< 6?C@==>6?E[ :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED 3C@F89E :? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?27D2]@C8^23@FE^23@FE\?27D2^:?E6C?2E:@?2=\DEF56?ED\4@?EC:3FE65\cb\3:==:@?\FD\64@?@>J\a_ac\a_ad\72==\a_adQm>@C6 E92? Sc_ 3:==:@? 2 J62Ck^2m]k^Am

kAm}@H[ 2D 2 ?6H 24256>:4 J62C 368:?D[ p>6C:42? 5@>:?2?46 :? 9:896C 65F42E:@? 8=@32==J :D :?4@?EC@G6CE:3=J :? 564=:?6[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 52E2[ :?E6C?2E:@?2= C2?<:?8D 2?5 :?56A6?56?E 6IA6CED[ 244@C5:?8 E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8Qm%96 w649:?86C #6A@CEk^2m] k^Am

kAm%96 D=:56 92D 366? 2446=6C2E65 3J 2 J62C 2?5 2 92=7 @7 7F?5:?8 4FED[ C6DEC:4E:@?D @? :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED 2?5 4FC3D @? H92E 42? 36 D2:5 @C E2F89E] qFE :E 3682? 367@C6 E9@D6 A@=:E:42= 492==6?86D[ H:E9 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^?46D]65]8@G^:A65D^EC6?586?6C2E@C^2AA^EC6?5\E23=6^a^bnEC6?5:?8l4@=F>?U2>AjG2=F6r@56l8C2?50E@E2=U2>AjC:5l`U2>Aj4:5l`cQm6?C@==>6?E 564=:?6Dk^2m[ =24<=FDE6C C6EFC?D @? 6G6C\C:D:?8 AC:46D 2?5 AF3=:4 >:DECFDE] k^Am

kAm“xE E2<6D 2 H9:=6 7@C 2== @7 E96D6 AC@3=6>D E@ EC:4<=6 5@H?[ 3FE E96J 2C6 368:??:?8 E@ EC:4<=6 5@H?[” D2:5 tC:4 |=J?[ 2 724F=EJ 76==@H 2E E96 z6?2? x?DE:EFE6 7@C tE9:4D 2E sF<6 &?:G6CD:EJ H9@ DEF5:6D 24256>:4 7C665@>]k^Am

kAm%@A D49@=2CD 2C6 =62G:?8] u6H6C :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED 2C6 4@>:?8] &]$] F?:G6CD:E:6D 2C6 D=:AA:?8 :? :?E6C?2E:@?2= C2?<:?8D] p?5 p>6C:42? F?:G6CD:E:6D 92G6 72:=65 E@ <66A A246 2D @E96C 4@F?EC:6D A@FC C6D@FC46D :?E@ E96:C 9:896C 65F42E:@? DJDE6>D] k^Am

kAmr9:?6D6 :?DE:EFE:@?D[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ 92G6 :?4C62D65 E96:C AC@5F4E:@? @7 8C25F2E6D H:E9 5@4E@C2= 568C66D >F49 72DE6C E92? p>6C:42? @?6D :? E96 4C:E:42= 7:6=5D @7 D4:6?46[ E649?@=@8J[ 6?8:?66C:?8 2?5 >2E9] #2E96C E92? 6IA2?5:?8[ &]$] 5@4E@C2= AC@8C2>D 2C6 ?@H 25>:EE:?8 76H6C 42?5:52E6D @C 92G6 DE@AA65 2446AE:?8 ?6H 2AA=:42?ED 2=E@86E96C]k^Am

kAm%9:D 92D >JC:25 :>A24ED @? 2== p>6C:42?D] u2==:?8 369:?5 :? C6D62C49 :>A6C:=D E96 ?2E:@?’D 64@?@>:4 4@>A6E:E:G6?6DD[ 7@C :?DE2?46] p?5 2EEC24E:?8 76H6C :?E6C?2E:@?2= =62C?6CD — 2?5 E96 DF3D:5:6D E96J C6AC6D6?E E@ F?:G6CD:E:6D’ 3@EE@> =:?6D — :D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^2D\:?E6C?2E:@?2=\6?C@==>6?E\72==D\F\D\DEF56?ED\7246\AC@8C2>\4FED\2?5\9:896C\AC:46D^Qm2=C625J 27764E:?8 E96 D6CG:46D 2?5 >2;@CDk^2m 2G2:=23=6 E@ 5@>6DE:4 DEF56?ED[ 2?5 4@F=5 :?4C62D6 E96 4@DE]k^Am

kAm$@ 5:C6 92D E96 D:EF2E:@? 364@>6 E92E E96 p>6C:42? p4256>J @7 pCED 2?5 $4:6?46D 9@DE65 2 5:D4FDD:@? 23@FE :E :? yF?6] %96 E:E=6i “xD E96 &]$] {@D:?8 xED t586 2D 2 v=@32= t5F42E:@? {6256Cn” k^Am

kAm%96 2?DH6C :D J6D[ D2:5 |=J?[ H9@ H2D @?6 @7 E96 A2?6=:DED] “%96C6 2C6 D@ >2?J :DDF6D E9C62E6?:?8 p>6C:42’D 8=@32= DE2?5:?8[” 96 D2:5]k^Am

kAm%96 ?F>36C @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]BD]4@>^:?D:89ED^BD\H@C=5\F?:G6CD:EJ\C2?<:?8DQm&]$] F?:G6CD:E:6D :? E96 E@A `__k^2m @7 E96 "$ (@C=5 &?:G6CD:EJ #2?<:?8D 92D 72==6? 7C@> b` E@ ae :? E96 A2DE `_ J62CD[ H9:=6 r9:?6D6 F?:G6CD:E:6D 2C6 >@G:?8 FA] %96 %:>6D w:896C t5F42E:@? (@C=5 &?:G6CD:EJ #2?<:?8D DE:== AFED D6G6? &]$] F?:G6CD:E:6D 2>@?8 E96 E@A `_] qFE E96 D>2==6DE ?F>36C 6G6C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E:>6D9:896C65F42E:@?]4@>^?6HD^H@C=5\F?:G6CD:EJ\C2?<:?8D\a_ae\C6DF=ED\2??@F?465Qm>256 E96 E@A d__k^2m[ H9:=6 pD:2? F?:G6CD:E:6D C@D6] k^Am

kAmx?E6C?2E:@?2= DE2?5:?8D =:<6 E96D6 “2C6 E96 8=@32= DJ>3@= 7@C 86@A@=:E:42= DEC6?8E9 @? E96 H@C=5 DE286[ 2?5 E96J’C6 G6CJ :?7=F6?E:2= :? A6@A=6’D 564:D:@? 23@FE H96C6 E@ DEF5J[” D2:5 !9:= q2EJ[ E96 %:>6D w:896C’D 49:67 8=@32= 2772:CD @77:46C] “x7 J@F DE2CE D66:?8 E96 D=@H 5:>:?FE:@? @7 C2?<:?8D[ E92E >62?D J@F’C6 364@>:?8 =6DD 2EEC24E:G6 E@ E92E E2=6?E] %96? :E 4@F=5 36 2 C62==J D6C:@FD 5@H?H2C5 DA:C2=]”k^Am

kAmx? E96 ?6IE %:>6D w:896C C2?<:?8D — 5F6 @FE $6AE] b_ — &]$] :?DE:EFE:@?D 4@?E:?F6 E@ 72== :? 4@>A2C2E:G6 >62DFC6D @7 C6AFE2E:@? 2?5 C6D62C49 BF2=:EJ[ q2EJ D2:5]k^Am

kAm“xE 5@6D 766= =:<6 2 E:AA:?8 A@:?E[” 96 D2:5] k^Am

kAm&?:G6CD:E:6D :? r9:?2 2??F2==J EFC? @FE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^?4D6D]?D7]8@G^:?5:42E@CDQm?62C=J d_ A6C46?E >@C6 !9]s] 8C25F2E6Dk^2m :? D4:6?46[ E649?@=@8J[ 6?8:?66C:?8 2?5 >2E9 E92? &]$] F?:G6CD:E:6D 5@[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 }2E:@?2= $4:6?46 u@F?52E:@?[ @C }$u] %92E’D A2CE=J 2 C67=64E:@? @7 r9:?2’D =2C86C A@AF=2E:@?] qFE E96 A246 @7 $%t| !9]s] AC@5F4E:@? :D 2=D@ C:D:?8 >F49 >@C6 BF:4<=J :? r9:?2 E92? :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D] xE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]75::?E6==:86?46]4@>^4@?E6?E^5_2dg7bh\_65_\c3dg\g4d`\cff`bb3e5h6`nI?A60E:74Qm5@F3=65 :? E96 `d J62CD 6?5:?8 :? a_aak^2m[ H9:=6 E96 ?F>36C @7 &]$] !9]s] 8C25F2E6D :? $%t| C@D6 EH@\7:7E9D 2D 72DE[ @C 3J c` A6C46?E[ 2? 2?2=JD:D 3J 7s: x?E6==:86?46 7@F?5]k^Am

kAmr9:?6D6 F?:G6CD:E:6D ?@H 9@=5 D6G6? @7 E96 E@A `_ A=246D :? E96 {6:56? #2?<:?8D 7C@> E96 r6?EC6 7@C $4:6?46 2?5 %649?@=@8J $EF5:6D 2E {6:56? &?:G6CD:EJ[ H9:49 C2?<D :?DE:EFE:@?D 32D65 @? E96 ?F>36C @7 ;@FC?2= 2CE:4=6D AF3=:D965 3J E96:C 724F=E:6D — 2 D66>:?8=J 2C42?6 3FE 4@?D6BF6?E:2= >62DFC6 @7 24256>:4 AC@5F4E:G:EJ :? H9:49 w2CG2C5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^EC25:E:@?2=]=6:56?C2?<:?8]4@>^C2?<:?8^a_ad^=:DEQm92D 72==6? 7C@> 7:CDE :? E96 H@C=5 E@ E9:C5k^2m] k^Am

kAm#6D62C496CD :? r9:?2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2=>2?24]6E@]E649^E@A:4D^2:^QmAC@5F465 ag A6C46?E @7 t?8=:D9 =2?8F286 2CE:4=6D 23@FE 2CE:7:4:2= :?E6==:86?46k^2m[ H@C=5H:56[ 36EH66? a_`g 2?5 a_ab[ 4@>A2C65 H:E9 `e A6C46?E 3J D49@=2CD :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 t>6C8:?8 %649?@=@8J ~3D6CG2E@CJ 2E v6@C86E@H? &?:G6CD:EJ] k^Am

kAm(9:=6 E96J >2J 92G6 AC@5F465 =6DD C6D62C49 5FC:?8 E92E A6C:@5 E92? E96:C r9:?6D6 4@F?E6CA2CED[ p>6C:42? D49@=2CD DE:== C2?<65 9:896C @? 9@H @7E6? E96:C H@C< H2D 4:E65 3J @E96CD[ E96 }$u ?@E65 — 2? :>A@CE2?E :?5:42E:@? @7 :ED C6=2E:G6 BF2=:EJ] p?5 D@>6 @7 E96 >@DE AC6DE:8:@FD &]$] F?:G6CD:E:6D H6C6 DE:== 9@=5:?8 E96:C @H? 2E E96 E@A @7 E9@D6 >@DE C646?E :?E6C?2E:@?2= C2?<:?8D]k^Am

kAmqFE E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 92D D:?46 4FE 3:==:@?D @7 5@==2CD :? C6D62C49 7F?5:?8[ C6DF=E:?8 :? =2J@77D 2?5 F?46CE2:?EJ] p?5 H9:=6 >2?J @7 E9@D6 :?:E:2= 4FED H6C6 C6DE@C65 3J 4@FCED[ 7656C2= 286?4:6D 92G6 D=@H65 E96 2H2C5:?8 @7 ?6H 8C2?ED] k^Am

kAm%96 25>:?:DEC2E:@?’D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]H9:E69@FD6]8@G^HA\4@?E6?E^FA=@25D^a_ae^_c^3F586E07Ja_af]A57n:?=:?6l`Qma_af 3F586E C6BF6DEk^2m H@F=5 C65F46 DA6?5:?8 @? E96 }$u 2?5 }2E:@?2= x?DE:EFE6D @7 w62=E9 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]3C6??2?46?E6C]@C8^@FC\H@C<^C6D62C49\C6A@CED^4@DE\ECF>A\25>:?:DEC2E:@?D\2EE24<D\C6D62C49\7F?5:?8Qm3J dd A6C46?E 2?5 `b A6C46?Ek^2m[ C6DA64E:G6=J[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 ?@?A2CE:D2? =2H 2?5 A@=:4J @C82?:K2E:@? E96 qC6??2? r6?E6C 7@C yFDE:46[ 2?5 D9:7E D@>6 @7 H92E >@?6J C6>2:?D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D4:6?46]@C8^4@?E6?E^2CE:4=6^ECF>A\25G:D6C\D\8@=56?\286\C6A@CE\F\D\D4:6?46\>:DD65\@AA@CEF?:EJ\4C:E:4D\D2JQm2H2J 7C@> F?:G6CD:E:6Dk^2m] k^Am

kAm“(6 92G6 E96 DF446DD @7 E96 A@DEH2C A6C:@5 E@ D9@H E92E E96 4FCC6?E >@56= H@C<D AC6EEJ H6==[” D2:5 $E6G6? sFC=2F7[ 2? 64@?@>:DE 2E E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 r9:428@’D w2CC:D $49@@= @7 !F3=:4 !@=:4J[ C676CC:?8 E@ E96 9:DE@C:4 C@=6 @7 E96 7656C2= 8@G6C?>6?E :? DFAA@CE:?8 24256>:4 C6D62C49] %@52J[ H:E9 7F?5:?8 F?46CE2:?EJ 2E =62DE 2?5 4FED 2E H@CDE[ D2:5 sFC=2F7[ “H6’C6 @? 2 DF:4:52= EC2;64E@CJ]”k^Am

kAmq=2>:?8 E96 :?E6CCFAE:@?D :? 7F?5:?8 E92E 92G6 2=C625J @44FCC65[ E@A C6D62C49 F?:G6CD:E:6D 92G6 25>:EE65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]22F]65F^?6HDC@@>^=625:?8\C6D62C49\F?:G6CD:E:6D\C6A@CE^?6H\A95\25>:DD:@?D\52E2\D9@H\E9C62E\FD\DE6>\H@C<7@C46nFE>042>A2:8?l}6IEZ?6HD=6EE6CZD2>A=6Z42>A2:8?U2>AjFE>0>65:F>l6>2:=U2>Aj09D6?4lAap}BEK\gIKsKaf%2}r%r+`ahuH>pAAq\4g3*v7Ffd4<*ayshD~c!I)y"g3~=qd7f?uJ%ch<Jh$y@?@b;#vyF*$\vwp>vC*~|f5d_C}Gf{6>6xK8"9eu((f`|U2>Aj09D>:lcafeebfggU2>AjFE>04@?E6?ElcafeebfggU2>AjFE>0D@FC46l9D06>2:=Qm`d A6C46?E 76H6C 5@4E@C2= DEF56?EDk^2m 7@C E96 4@>:?8 72==[ :?4=F5:?8 :? 7:6=5D DF49 2D 2CE:7:4:2= :?E6==:86?46 2?5 BF2?EF> 4@>AFE:?8[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 pDD@4:2E:@? @7 p>6C:42? &?:G6CD:E:6D[ @C pp&] |2?J 5:5?’E E2<6 2?J ?6H 5@4E@C2= DEF56?ED 2E 2==] k^Am

kAms@4E@C2= AC@8C2>D EC2:? D4:6?E:DED E@ E6249 2?5 4@?5F4E C6D62C49 :? 7:6=5D :?4=F5:?8 E649?@=@8J 2?5 EC62E>6?ED 7@C >65:42= AC@3=6>D]k^Am

kAm“p>6C:42 7246D E96 2=2C>:?8 AC@DA64E @7 =@D:?8 2? 6?E:C6 86?6C2E:@? @7 D4:6?E:7:4 E2=6?E[” E96 pp& D2JD] k^Am

kAmyFDE 27E6C E96 DE2CE @7 E96 D64@?5 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@?[ 23@FE 92=7 @7 !9]s] DEF56?ED 2?5 A@DE5@4E@C2= C6D62C496CD :? 3:@6?8:?66C:?8 D2:5 E96J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?36C]@C8^A2A6CD^Hbdbb_QmH6C6 =:<6=J E@ =62G6 24256>:2k^2m[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 2 DFCG6J 3J C6D62C496CD 2E w2CG2C5[ |x% 2?5 6=D6H96C6] %96 AC@A@CE:@? H9@ D2:5 E96J’5 =:<6=J =62G6 E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D H2D 2=D@ FA]k^Am

kAm%9C66 :? 7@FC &]$]\32D65 C6D62C496CD @G6C2== k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?2EFC6]4@>^2CE:4=6D^5c`dge\_ad\__hbg\JQm92G6 4@?D:56C65 =62G:?8 E96 4@F?ECJk^2m[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 2?@E96C DFCG6J[ 3J E96 ;@FC?2= }2EFC6[ 4@?5F4E65 367@C6 D@>6 @7 E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@?’D 92CD96DE 24E:@?D 282:?DE F?:G6CD:E:6D 2?5 4@==686D] k^Am

kAmu@CEJ\7:G6 A6C46?E @7 724F=EJ :? J6E 2?@E96C DFCG6J[ 3J C6D62C496CD 2E E96 w2CG2C5 vC25F2E6 $49@@= @7 t5F42E:@?[ D2:5 E96J 925 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^4@2496]8D6]92CG2C5]65F^724F=EJ\C6E6?E:@?\2?5\6I:E\DFCG6JQm4@?D:56C65 ;@3D @FED:56 @7 9:896C 65F42E:@?k^2m :? E96 =2DE E9C66 J62CD[ 2?5 2 E9:C5 E92E E96J 925 4@?D:56C65 @AA@CEF?:E:6D @FED:56 @7 E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D] |@DE D2:5 492?86D :? DE2E6 @C 7656C2= A@=:4J H6C6 :?DECF>6?E2= :? E96:C ;@3 D62C496D]k^Am

kAmpE =62DE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4??]4@>^a_ad^_h^ah^49:?2^49:?2\C6G6CD6\3C2:?\5C2:?\D4:6?46\E649\4@>A6E:E:@?\FD\:?E=\9?<Qmgd D49@=2CD 92G6 >@G65 E@ r9:?2k^2m D:?46 E96 DE2CE @7 a_ac[ r}} C6A@CE:?8 7@F?5[ :?4=F5:?8 D6G6C2= 2E E96 E@A @7 E96:C 7:6=5D — >@DE C646?E=J[ }@36= !C:K6\H:??:?8 496>:DE ~>2C *289:[ H9@ :D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]=2E:>6D]4@>^D4:6?46^DE@CJ^a_ae\_f\`_^?@36=\AC:K6\H:??6C\=62G:?8\F4\36C<6=6J\7@C\?6H\C@=6\:?\49:?2Qm=62G:?8 E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 r2=:7@C?:2[ q6C<6=6Jk^2m[ 7@C %D:?89F2 &?:G6CD:EJ :? r9:?2 E@ 96=A 6DE23=:D9 2? :?DE:EFE6 E92E H:== FD6 px E@ DA665 FA E96 56G6=@A>6?E @7 ?6H >2E6C:2=D] k^Am

kAmp>6C:42? D4:6?E:DED 4@==64E:G6=J DF3>:EE65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?2EFC6]4@>^2CE:4=6D^5c`dge\_ad\_`a`e\fQmba A6C46?E >@C6 2AA=:42E:@?D 7@C ;@3D 23C@25k^2m :? E96 7:CDE BF2CE6C @7 =2DE J62C E92? :? E96 D2>6 A6C:@5 E96 J62C 367@C6[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 2 D6A2C2E6 2?2=JD:D 3J }2EFC6]k^Am

kAm&]$] F?:G6CD:E:6D “92G6 366? >28?6ED 7@C E2=6?E 3642FD6 E96J 92G6 AC@G:565 2? 6I492?86i ‘r@>6 3F:=5 J@FC C6D62C49 =23 2E @FC F?:G6CD:EJ — J@F’== 86E 2== E96D6 E2=6?E65 DEF56?ED[ H6 92G6 =23D[ H6 92G6 8@G6C?>6?E 7F?5:?8[’ ” D2:5 zF>2C v2C8[ 2 D4:6?46 2?5 E649?@=@8J 25G:D6C :? E96 ~32>2 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 2?5 ?@H AC6D:56?E @7 #6?2:DD2?46 !9:=2?E9C@AJ[ H9:49 96=AD 492??6= AC:G2E6 7F?5D E@ C6D62C49] “x7 E92E 3F?5=6 DE2CED F?C2G6=:?8[ E9:D ?@ =@?86C H@C<D]”k^Am

kAm|62?H9:=6[ E96 7=@H @7 :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED 4@>:?8 E@ E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D 92D D=@H65 5C2>2E:42==J[ H:E9 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^2D\:?E6C?2E:@?2=\6?C@==>6?E\72==D\F\D\DEF56?ED\7246\AC@8C2>\4FED\2?5\9:896C\AC:46D^Qm2D >F49 2D 2 aa A6C46?E 564=:?6k^2m :? E96 ?F>36C H9@ 2CC:G65 =2DE DF>>6C 4@>A2C65 H:E9 E96 DF>>6C 367@C6] k^Am

kAm}62C=J D:I :? `_ F?:G6CD:E:6D 2?5 4@==686D D2J E96 ?F>36C @7 2AA=:42E:@?D E96J C646:G65 7C@> :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^::6]H:56?]?6E^D^<eB;8?KC93^DAC:?80a_ae0D?2AD9@E0C6A@CEQm76== 282:? 7@C E96 24256>:4 J62C 23@FE E@ DE2CEk^2m[ 2 DFCG6J 3J E96 x?DE:EFE6 @7 x?E6C?2E:@?2= t5F42E:@? 7@F?5] |@C6 E92? c_ A6C46?E C6A@CE65 2 “DF3DE2?E:2=” 564=:?6 :? 2AA=:42E:@?D 7@C 8C25F2E6 DEF5J] }pu$pi pDD@4:2E:@? @7 x?E6C?2E:@?2= t5F42E@CD 2?5 E96 65F42E:@? E649?@=@8J 4@>A2?J yq x?E6C?2E:@?2= AC@;64E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]?27D2]@C8^72==a_ae@FE=@@<Qm2 5C@A @7 ```[___ :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?EDk^2m E9:D 72==[ 4@DE:?8 E96 64@?@>J Sb]c 3:==:@?]k^Am

kAm“%96 &]$] 92D E9C:G65 3642FD6 E96 H@C=5’D D>2CE6DE A6@A=6 7=@4< E@ E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D[ 2?5 E92E :D 567:?:E6=J DE2==:?8[” D2:5 q2EJ[ @7 E96 %:>6D w:896C] k^Am

kAm%9:D D=:56 7@==@HD 7656C2= 56=2JD :? :DDF:?8 ?6H DEF56?E G:D2D[ E96 56E6?E:@?D 2?5 56A@CE2E:@?D @7 :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED 7@C E96:C A@=:E:42= 24E:G:D> 2?5 D4C66?:?8D @7 :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?E 2AA=:42?ED’ D@4:2= >65:2 A@DED] k^Am

kAmtG6? 367@C6 E9@D6 DE6AD[ 9@H6G6C — 2D E96 AC:46 @7 &]$] 9:896C 65F42E:@? 4@?E:?F65 E@ C:D6 — “4@DE H2D 2 =2C86C C62D@?” 7@C :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED C64@?D:56C:?8 4@>:?8 E@ E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D[ D2:5 #@?2 pJ5:?[ H9@ H@C<D H:E9 E96> 2D 7@F?56C @7 E96 :?E6C?2E:@?2= 4@==686 25>:DD:@?D 4@F?D6=:?8 4@>A2?J ~C:6= p5>:DD:@?D]k^Am

kAm}@H[ D2:5 pJ5:?[ AC@DA64E:G6 2AA=:42?ED H9@ AC6G:@FD=J H@F=5 92G6 @?=J 4@?D:56C65 p>6C:42? F?:G6CD:E:6D “2C6 2=D@ E9:?<:?8 23@FE 324<FA 4@F?EC:6D] %92E’D 2 D9:7E]”k^Am

kAm*6E 2?@E96C CF=6[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]59D]8@G^?6HD^a_ae^_f^`e^ECF>A\25>:?:DEC2E:@?\:DDF6D\7:?2=\CF=6\6?5\7@C6:8?\DEF56?E\G:D2\23FD6QmC6DEC:4E:?8 :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED E@ 7@FC J62CD :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6Dk^2m[ E2<6D 67764E $6AE] `d] u@FC J62CD :D =6DD E:>6 E92? :D ?66565 E@ 4@>A=6E6 >2?J !9]s] 2?5 @E96C 24256>:4 AC@8C2>D[ 2?5 E96 ?6H =:>:E :D =:<6=J E@ 7FCE96C C65F46 E96 DFAA=J @7 :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?ED 4@>:?8 E@ E96 4@F?ECJ]k^Am

kAmp=D@[ H9:=6 :E’D DE:== E@@ 62C=J E@ D66 E96:C 67764ED[ ?6H =:>:ED @? 7656C2= =@2?D 7@C 8C25F2E6 DEF5J H:== =62G6 23@FE @?6\7@FCE9 @7 5@>6DE:4 8C25F2E6\D49@@= 3@CC@H6CD F?23=6 E@ 4@?E:?F6 E@ A2J 7@C E96:C 65F42E:@?D[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]2>6C:42?]65F^DA2^A66C^FA=@25^=@2?\=:>:ED\7C@>\?AD2D0CAE07:?2=]A57QmAC@;64E:@?D DF886DEk^2m]k^Am

kAmx? D@>6 DE2E6D[ 724F=EJ 92G6 72465 4@?DEC2:?ED @? H92E E96J 42? E6249 2?5 E9C62ED E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^369:?5\E96\EFC>@:=\@7\7656C2=\2EE24<D\@?\4@==686D\D@>6\DE2E6D\2C6\8@:?8\27E6C\E6?FC6^QmAC@E64E:@?D DF49 2D E6?FC6k^2m] k^Am

kAmx?DE:EFE:@?2= 2FE@?@>J 2E &]$] F?:G6CD:E:6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^24256>:4\7C665@>\:?56I]?6E^Qm92D 6C@565 3J d_ A6C46?Ek^2m :? E96 564256 6?5:?8 :? a_ad[ 2?5 6DA64:2==J D:?46 E96 7:CDE %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@?[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 p4256>:4 uC665@> x?56I AC@5F465 3J C6D62C496CD 2E v6C>2?J’D &?:G6CD:EJ @7 tC=2?86?\}FC6>36C8] k^Am

kAm“%96 564=:?6 :? :?DE:EFE:@?2= 2FE@?@>J :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D DE2?5D @FE 2D 2 42D6 @7 72DE 2?5 DE66A 56E6C:@C2E:@?[” E96 C6D62C496CD HC@E6 :? |2C49]k^Am

kAm%6?FC6 42? <66A D4:6?E:DED 7C@> =62G:?8 24256>:2 7@C 36EE6C\A2J:?8 ;@3D :? AC:G2E6 :?5FDECJ[ 2D >@C6 >2J ?@H 5@[ D2:5 z6?2? $29:?[ 2FE9@C @7 “p>6C:42? t5F42E:@?2= tI46==6?46[” 2 3@@< 23@FE E96 DEC6?8E9D @7 E96 &]$] 65F42E:@? DJDE6>[ 2?5 2 =:76 >6>36C @7 E96 8@G6C?:?8 3@2C5 2E |x%[ H9:49 96 2EE6?565 2D 2? :?E6C?2E:@?2= DEF56?E 367@C6 7@F?5:?8 H92E H@F=5 364@>6 2 >F=E:3:==:@?\5@==2C E649 4@>A2?J]k^Am

kAm%9@D6 C6D62C496CD H:E9@FE E6?FC6 H9@ C6>2:? 2E F?:G6CD:E:6D >2J DE:4< E@ “D276” :562D C2E96C E92? D66< @FE A@E6?E:2= 3C62<E9C@F89D 2?5 C:D< 72:=FC6[ $29:? D2:5]k^Am

kAm$6G6?EJ A6C46?E @7 p>6C:42?D ?@H D2J 9:896C 65F42E:@? :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D :D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A6HC6D62C49]@C8^D9@CE\C625D^a_ad^`_^`d^8C@H:?8\D92C6\@7\2>6C:42?D\D2J\E96\FD\9:896C\65F42E:@?\DJDE6>\:D\962565\:?\E96\HC@?8\5:C64E:@?^Qm8@:?8 :? E96 HC@?8 5:C64E:@?k^2m[ FA 7C@> de A6C46?E :? a_a_[ 244@C5:?8 E@ !6H] p5F=ED H9@ H6?E E@ 4@==686 2C6 >@C6 =:<6=J E@ D2J E9:D E92? E9@D6 H9@ 5:5?’E] k^Am

kAm%92E 72==@77 :? 4@?7:56?46 3682? 367@C6 E96 4FCC6?E A@=:E:42= 2EE24<D 2?5 :D =2C86=J 3642FD6 @7 A6@A=6’D D<6AE:4:D> 23@FE H92E E96J’C6 86EE:?8 7@C E96:C >@?6J[ !6H’D 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2A?6HD]4@>^2CE:4=6^9:896C\65F42E:@?\4@?7:56?46\DFCG6J\dfc6_a5gcfg5b4`2fdef2dc7e`27``7`Qm@E96C DFCG6JDk^2m D9@H]k^Am

kAm%96 &?:E65 $E2E6D DA6?5D 2>@?8k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^52E2\6IA=@C6C]@645]@C8^G:DnE>lDA6?5:?8ZE6CE:2CJZ65F42E:@?U2>AjA8l_U2>AjD?3lb`U2>AjGHlE3U2>Aj57Tdq5DTdsl5Ds:DD6>:?2E6u:?2=s|+U2>Aj57Tdq:5Tdsls$s0tpv0&~t0ux}osu0&~t0ux}0$~&#rt0v'0!#0}s~|U2>Aj57Tdq28Tdsl~trs]ts&]x|t!U2>Aj57TdqGDTdslb]aU2>Aj5Bl]]x$rts``0d%g]0%Taq$`bTaq$`s0}~}0ts&Taq$a]x}$%0ts&]]"Taq0+]&$s0!!!Taq!%0t)!Taq!%0q`v"]U2>AjA5la_`d[a_abU2>AjE@Tdq%x|t0!t#x~sTdslECF6Qm E96 >@DEk^2m :? E96 H@C=5 @? 9:896C 65F42E:@?[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 ~C82?:D2E:@? 7@C t4@?@>:4 r@\@A6C2E:@? 2?5 s6G6=@A>6?E[ @C ~trs] qFE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]@645]@C8^6?^AF3=:42E:@?D^65F42E:@?\2E\2\8=2?46\a_ad0`4_5h4fh\6?]9E>=Qm:E C2?<D `dE9 2?5 `fE9k^2m[ C6DA64E:G6=J[ :? E96 AC@A@CE:@? @7 ad\ E@ bc\J62C\@=5D H9@ 92G6 568C66D[ 56A6?5:?8 @? H96E96C E96:C A2C6?ED 5:5 @C 5:5?’E 8@ E@ 4@==686] %92E’D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]@645]@C8^6?^52E2^:?5:42E@CD^A@AF=2E:@?\H:E9\E6CE:2CJ\65F42E:@?]9E>=Qm5@H? 7C@> D64@?5k^2m @G6C2== a_ J62CD 28@]k^Am

kAm%96 :>A24E @7 E96D6 >2?J :?E6CD64E:?8 EC6?5D :D 2=C625J F?56CH2J] k^Am

kAm%96C6 92G6 366? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^4@==686\4FED]4@>^Qm>@C6 E92? ba_ :?DE2?46Dk^2m @7 4@==686 2?5 F?:G6CD:EJ =2J@77D[ AC@8C2> 4FED[ 56A2CE>6?E 6=:>:?2E:@?D 2?5 4=@D:?8D D:?46 y2?F2CJ a_ac[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 52E232D6 r@==686rFED[ H9:49 EC24<D E9:D] tG6? w2CG2C5’D u24F=EJ @7 pCED 2?5 $4:6?46D :D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E964C:>D@?]4@>^2CE:4=6^a_ad^``^d^72D\DECF4EFC2=\567:4:E^QmCF??:?8 2 Sbd_ >:==:@? 567:4:Ek^2m[ H9:49 :E 2EEC:3FE6D A2CE=J E@ 2? :?4C62D65 7656C2= E2I @? :ED 6?5@H>6?E]k^Am

kAm“&?:G6CD:E:6D H6?E E9C@F89 2 >F=E:564256 A6C:@5 H96C6 E96J 6I:DE65 :? 2 3:A2CE:D2? 92=@[ H96C6 A6@A=6 >:89E 5:D28C66 23@FE =@ED @7 E9:?8D[ 3FE 92G:?8 4FEE:?8\6586 F?:G6CD:E:6D H2D 2 E9:?8 6G6CJ3@5J 4@F=5 28C66 @? 2?5 H2D H:==:?8 E@ :?G6DE :?[” v2C8 D2:5]k^Am

kAm&]$] 9:896C 65F42E:@? :?DE:EFE:@?D “C62==J 2C6 566A H6==D @7 E2=6?E] %96:C DEC6?8E9D 2C6 C62=[” 96 D2:5] qFE “H6 D9@F=5 ?@E D=66A @? E96 724E E92E :7 H6 5@?’E 252AE 2?5 ?2G:82E6 E9:D >@>6?E[ H6’C6 8@:?8 E@ H2<6 FA 2?5 2== @7 E96 AC6>:6C F?:G6CD:E:6D H@?’E 36 :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D[ 2?5 H6’== H@?56C 9@H E92E 92AA6?65]”k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^@?46\8=@32==J\AC66>:?6?E\F\D\F?:G6CD:E:6D\2C6\D=:5:?8\:?E@\564=:?6^Qmk6>m%9:D DE@CJk^6>mk^2mk6>m H2D AC@5F465 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8Qmk6>m%96 w649:?86C #6A@CEk^6>mk^2mk6>m[ 2 ?@?AC@7:E[ :?56A6?56?E ?6HD @C82?:K2E:@? 7@4FD65 @? :?6BF2=:EJ 2?5 :??@G2E:@? :? 65F42E:@?[ 2?5 C6G:6H65 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F3D]=2^"_b<=8$#_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmk6>m$E24<6Ck^6>mk^2m]k^Am