Virginia's 'Lost Cause' symbols sought to glorify and rewrite Confederate stories

kAm|2CJ p??2 {66[ E96 H:5@H @7 r@?7656C2E6 v6?] #@36CE t] {66[ H2?E65 2 G6CD:@? @7 96C 9FD32?5’D =:76 E@=5] $@ D96 82G6 6I4=FD:G6 C:89ED E@ AC@>:?6?E D4F=AE@C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^C:49>@?5]4@>^?6HD^=@42=^8@GE\2?5\A@=:E:4D^H:E9\C6>@G2=\@7\2\A\9:==\>@?F>6?E\A6?5:?8\C:49>@?5\@77:4:2=D\DE:==\C6G:6H:?8\@776CD\7@C\7:?2=^2CE:4=60cgc_7f77\b74h\d66b\3ad2\d33_57gcd2ad]9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qmt5H2C5 ':C8:?:FD '2=6?E:?6k^2m E@ >2<6 9:D =:<6?6DD]k^Am

kAm'2=6?E:?6 4C62E65 2 EC:F>A92?E :E6C2E:@? @7 {66i 42?6 :? @?6 92?5[ 92E :? E96 @E96C] p D64@?5 H@C<[ 4@>>:DD:@?65 27E6C 9:D 562E9[ A@CEC2J65 9:> 2D 2 72==6?[ r9C:DE=:<6 96C@] '2=6?E:?6 H@F=5 8@ @? E@ >2<6 6:89E DE2EF6D @7 E96 DE@C:65 r:G:= (2C 86?6C2=[ H9@ 72>@FD=J C6D:8?65 9:D &]$] pC>J 4@>>:DD:@? E@ 7:89E 7@C E96 r@?7656C24J]k^Am

kAm(9:=6 >2?J AF3=:4 9@?@CD E@ E96 r@?7656C2E6 $E2E6D @7 p>6C:42 2?5 :ED =6256CD H6C6 5:D>2?E=65 7@==@H:?8 E96 <:==:?8 @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^C:49>@?5]4@>^86@C86\7=@J5D\<:==:?8\42AA65\J62CD\@7\G:@=6?46\5:D4C:>:?2E:@?\3J\>:??62A@=:D\A@=:46\5@;\D2JD^2CE:4=60af2`e`4g\eeg3\da_d\3673\c3g_be654f46]9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qmv6@C86 u=@J5 E9C66 J62CD 28@k^2m[ C6>:?56CD 4@>>6>@C2E:?8 $@FE96C? EC@@AD 2?5 =6256CD C6>2:? 24C@DD E96 DE2E6 — 7C@> >@?F>6?ED 2?5 DE2EF6D E@ E96 ?2>6D @7 D49@@=D[ DEC66ED 2?5 3F:=5:?8D] |2?J H6C6 3@C? :? E96 564256D 27E6C E96 r:G:= (2C[ H96? E96 D@\42==65 “{@DE r2FD6” >@G6>6?E @7 C67C2>:?8 E96 4@?7=:4E 2D 2? :DDF6 @7 DE2E6D’ C:89ED[ ?@E D=2G6CJ[ E@@< 9@=5]k^Am

kAmt249 92D 2 F?:BF6 @C:8:? DE@CJ[ 3FE >2?J D92C6 2 4@>>@? G:D:@?i @?6 @7 8=@C:7J:?8 2?5 C6HC:E:?8 E96 DE@C:6D @7 >6? H9@ 5:65 7:89E:?8 7@C E96 r@?7656C2E6 42FD6]k^Am

kAm%96:C 49C@?:4=6CD[ =:<6 '2=6?E:?6[ H6C6 <66?=J 2H2C6 @7 H92E E96J H6C6 5@:?8]k^Am

kAm“w6’D @FE E96C6 D4F=AE:?8 E96D6 >@?F>6?ED[ 2?5 96’D 567:?:E:G6=J 4@?EC:3FE:?8 E@ @FC 4@>>F?:EJ’D F?56CDE2?5:?8[ 2?5 >:DF?56CDE2?5:?8[ @7 E96 C@=6 E92E D=2G6CJ A=2J65 :? E96 r:G:= (2C’D @C:8:?D[” D2:5 r9C:DE:?6 z] ':52[ 4FC2E@C 2E %96 '2=6?E:?6[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E96G2=6?E:?6]@C8^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm2 >FD6F> AC6D6CG:?8 #:49>@?5’D 9:DE@CJ H96C6 '2=6?E:?6 H2D AC6D:56?E 7C@> `ghg E@ `hb_]k^2mk^Am

k2D:56 4=2DDlQE?4>D\:?=:?6\C6=4@?E6?E E?4>D\:?=:?6\C6=4@?E6?E\:?7@ E?4>D\:?=:?6\2=:8?>6?E\46?E6C E?4>D\:?=:?6\H:5E9\EH@\E9:C5DQmk9cmp3@FE E9:D DE@CJk^9cmkAm%96 <:==:?8 @7 v6@C86 u=@J5 E9C66 J62CD 28@ C6DF=E65 :? E96 C6>@G2= @7 r@?7656C2E6 DE2EF6D 2?5 DJ>3@=D :? ?F>6C@FD 4@>>F?:E:6D 24C@DD ':C8:?:2] x? 2 E9C66\A2CE D6C:6D[ H6 =@@< 2E H9:49 @?6D C6>2:? — 2?5 H92E 4@>6D ?6IE]k^Am kAmkDEC@?8m!2CE @?6ik^DEC@?8m |@C6 E92? `__ @7 ':C8:?:2’D r@?7656C2E6 >6>@C:2=D 92G6 4@>6 5@H?] qFE E96 AC@46DD 92D 366? 4@>A=6I]k^Am kAmkDEC@?8m!2CE EH@ik^DEC@?8m w@H DE2EF6D 4C62E65 >JE9@=@8:42= 492C24E6CD 7C@> r@?7656C2E6 86?6C2=D]k^Am kAmkDEC@?8m!2CE E9C66ik^DEC@?8m x? E96 {J?493FC8 C68:@?[ =6DD >@G6>6?E E@H2C5D 5:D>2?E=:?8 :4@?@8C2A9Jk^Amk^2D:56m

kAm%96 C@==\@FE @7 >@?F>6?ED DE2CE65 :? #:49>@?5 :? `geh[ 2 A6C:@5 A@4<>2C<65 3J 64@?@>:4 5@H?EFC?D] %96 7@C>6C 42A:E2= @7 E96 r@?7656C24J H2D 7:==65 H:E9 H@F?565 r@?7656C2E6 G6E6C2?D[ 3FE 2=D@ E96 368:??:?8D @7 2? 64@?@>:4 >:55=6 4=2DD]k^Am

kAmpE E96 E:>6[ {66’D DE2EF6 @? 9@CD6324< H2D E96 @?=J =2C86\D42=6 H@C< A=2??65 3J =@42= 3@@DE6CD] p4C@DD E96 @462?[ uC2?46 925 ;FDE 563FE65 E96 t:776= %@H6C] }6H *@C< 925 :ED @H? 8C2?5 2G6?F6D] x? #:49>@?5[ E96C6 H2D 2 D:>:=2C 2AA6E:E6 7@C 2 362FE:7F= >@56C? 3@F=6G2C5j {66’D 7@CE94@>:?8 DE2EF6 D=@EE65 ?62E=J :?E@ E92E G:D:@?]k^Am

kAm“xE H2D 2? 2EE6>AE 7@C #:49>@?5 E@ 364@>6 >@56C?[” D2:5 q:== |2CE:?[ 5:C64E@C @7 %96 '2=6?E:?6]k^Am

kAm“(9:=6 2E E96 D2>6 E:>6[ C6249:?8 324< E@ E96 A2DE[” ':52 D2:5]k^Am

kAmx? `gh_[ |@?F>6?E pG6?F6 — E96 =627J >2?D:@?\=:?65 E9@C@F8972C6 E92E H@F=5 364@>6 9@>6 E@ D6G6C2= r@?7656C2E6 >@?F>6?ED — H2D ?@E 2? :562 J6E[ ':52 D2:5] %96 E2D< 2E 92?5 H2D D:>A=J E@ 7:?5 2 A=246 7@C {66’D DE2EF6] xE H@F?5 FA :? E96 46?E6C @7 E96 p==6? 6DE2E6 — 2 DAC2H=:?8 A=@E @7 =2?5 @H?65 3J H62=E9J 3C:4< >2D@? (:==:2> r] p==6? — H9:49 H2D 36:?8 5:G:565 FA :?E@ C6D:56?E:2= =@ED]k^Am

kAm“xE C62==J H2D 2 C62= 6DE2E6 56G6=@A>6?E[” ':52 D2:5] “p?5 2E E96 46?E6CA:646 H2D E9:D A:646 @7 AF3=:4 2CE]”k^Am

k9amVxE E2<6D E96 HC@?8 DE6A :? 5@:?8 D@Vk^9am

kAmp4C@DD E@H?[ #:49>@?5’D y24<D@? (2C5 H2D 368:??:?8 E@ 4@2=6D46 2C@F?5 H:E9 q=24<\@H?65 32?<D 2?5 :?DFC2?46 4@>A2?:6D] q=24< ?6HDA2A6CD[ =:<6 E96 #:49>@?5 !=2?6E[ 7:6C46=J @AA@D65 E96 :?4@>:?8 DE2EF6D] y@9? |:E496== yC][ E96 A2A6C’D 7:6CJ 65:E@C[ D4@C?65 E96 {66 >@?F>6?EVD F?G6:=:?8[ H9:49 H2D 7F?565 3J E96 4:EJ 2?5 2EE6?565 3J E9@FD2?5D H2G:?8 r@?7656C2E6 7=28D]k^Am

kAm“%96 $@FE9 >2J C6G6C6 E96 >6>@CJ @7 :ED 49:67E2:?D[” C625 2 7C@?E\A286 65:E@C:2=] “xE E2<6D E96 HC@?8 DE6A :? 5@:?8 D@]”k^Am

kAmqFE DE6A E96J 5:5[ 5:G:?8 566A6C :?E@ H92E 3642>6 <?@H? 2D “{@DE r2FD6” :56@=@8J — E96 :562 E92E E96 $@FE9’D 42FD6 H2D 96C@:4[ C2E96C E92? 4CF6= @C D=2G6\46?EC:4] r@?7656C2E6 >@?F>6?ED >F=E:A=:65[ BF:4<=J 364@>:?8 E@FC:DE 2EEC24E:@?D] p>@?8 E96> H2D %96 '2=6?E:?6[ H9:49 @A6?65 :? `ghg] %96 AC:G2E6 >FD6F> 9@FD65 E96 DEF5:@ :? H9:49 '2=6?E:?6 4C62E65 9:D DE2EF6D @7 {66 2?5 y6776CD@? s2G:D[ E96 @?=J AC6D:56?E @7 E96 r@?7656C2E6 $E2E6D @7 p>6C:42]k^Am

kAm'2=6?E:?6’D H@C< DAC625 24C@DD E96 DE2E6] w6 3F:=E 2 DE2EF6 E@ r@?7656C2E6 v6?] %9@>2D y] Q$E@?6H2==Q y24<D@?[ H9:49 H@F=5 DE2?5 D6?E:?6= @G6C 9:D 8C2G6 :? {6I:?8E@?] w6 D4F=AE65 2?@E96C 56A:4E:?8 E96 p>6C:42? #6G@=FE:@?2CJ (2C qC:8] v6?] wF89 |6C46C[ 56DE:?65 7@C uC656C:4<D3FC8] p?5 2 E9:C5 E@ r@?7656C2E6 $E2E6D #6A] (:==:2>D r2CE6C (:4<92> E92E DE@@5 7@C J62CD :? #:49>@?5’D |@?C@6 !2C<]k^Am

kAm%9:D H2G6 @7 >@?F>6?E 4@?DECF4E:@? A62<65 :? `h`` 2?5 5:5 ?@E 6?5 F?E:= E96 `hb_D] $E2EF6D E@ s2G:D 2?5 r@?7656C2E6 v6?] y]t]q] $EF2CE H6?E FA :? `h_f 2=@?8 |@?F>6?E pG6?F6 :? #:49>@?5] p?5 24C@DD E96 DE2E6[ D:>:=2C >6>@C:2=D D66>65 E@ >F=E:A=J[ H:E9 DEC66ED[ D49@@=D 2?5 6?E:C6 4@F?E:6D 36:?8 C6?2>65]k^Am

kAm|2?J H6C6 DA@?D@C65 3J r@?7656C2E6 EC:3FE6 8C@FAD[ 2>@?8 E96> E96 &?:E65 s2F89E6CD @7 E96 r@?7656C24J 2?5 E96 $@?D @7 r@?7656C2E6 '6E6C2?D] Wq@E9 @C82?:K2E:@?D 564=:?65 E@ 4@>>6?E 7@C E9:D DE@CJ]Xk^Am

kAm“~FC C2?<D 2C6 E9:??:?8 52:=J[” C625 2 `hae C6A@CE 7C@> E96 $@?D @7 r@?7656C2E6 '6E6C2?D] “p?5 @FC =@G65 C6AC6D6?E2E:G6D D9@F=5 DE6A :? ?@H 2?5 2CC2?86 E@ E2<6 492C86 @7 $@FE96C? 9:DE@CJ[ @FC C6=:4D[ >6>6?E@D[ 2?5 >@?F>6?ED[ 2?5 DE:>F=2E6 E96 6C64E:@? @7 @E96C >@?F>6?ED E@ @FC 96C@6D]”k^Am

kAm%96:C 42== H2D 966565 3J C:49 7:?2?4:6CD] ~?6[ !2F= v@@5=@6 |4x?E:C6[ 2? :?G6DE@C 2?5 AC@=:7:4 5@?@C E@ E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 ':C8:?:2[ A2:5 7@C E96 DE2EF6D @7 3@E9 {66 2?5 y24<D@? E92E H@F=5 4@>6 E@ 567:?6 r92C=@EE6DG:==6]k^Am

kAm%96C6 H6C6 @E96C C6>:?56CD[ E@@]k^Am

kAmyFDE D@FE9 @7 uC656C:4<D3FC8[ E96 DE2E6 AC6D6CG65 E96 9@FD6 H96C6 y24<D@? 5:65[ =:DE:?8 :E 2D 2 “D9C:?6” :? `hbc] xE’D D:?46 366? C6?2>65 2D 2 “562E9 D:E6]”k^Am

kAm|:4926= r2CE6C[ 2 q=24< 72C>6C H9@ 8C6H FA :? r2C@=:?6 r@F?EJ[ A2DD65 E96 y24<D@? D9C:?6 6249 52J @? 9:D H2J E@ D49@@=] r2CE6C EC246D 9:D A2C6?E286 E@ 2?46DE@CD H9@ H6C6 6?D=2G65 2E E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9:DE@C:4D9:C=6J]4@>^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm$9:C=6J !=2?E2E:@?k^2m[ 2? 6DE2E6 :? r92C=6D r:EJ r@F?EJ E92E 52E6D E@ `e`c]k^Am

kAmr2CE6C D2:5 :E’D EC@F3=:?8 E92E y24<D@? H2D 8:G6? DF49 2? 9@?@C]k^Am

kAm“xE’D C62==J 2?E:\q=24<?6DD] %92E E96J H@F=5 92G6 2 D9C:?6 E@ D@>6@?6 H9@ 6?D=2G65 @E96C A6@A=6 — :E’D DFA6C:@C:EJ[” r2CE6C D2:5] “}@ >2EE6C 9@H 72C J@F AC@8C6DD :? D@4:6EJ[ J@FC A=246 :D 36?62E9 FD[ 2?5 E96D6 2C6 E96 >@?F>6?ED @7 H9@ J@F D9@F=5 92G6 366? D6CG:?8]”k^Am

kAmr2CE6C D2JD 96’D 2 DEF56?E @7 E96 r:G:= (2C] w6 ?@E6D E92E $@FE96C? r:G:= (2C 96C@6D H9@ 7@F89E D=2G6CJ H6C6 ?6G6C G2=@C:K65] w6 A@:?ED E@ 9:DE@C:42= 7:8FC6D =:<6 (:==:2> p] y24<D@?[ E96 q=24< D6CG2?E E@ s2G:D H9@ A6C7@C>65 6DA:@?286 7@C E96 &?:@?]k^Am

kAm}@C 5:5 ':C8:?:2?D 3F:=5 DE2EF6D E@ E96 32EE2=:@?D @7 q=24< D@=5:6CD H9@ 7@F89E :? E96 q2EE=6 @7 #:49>@?5 2?5 E96 $:686 @7 !6E6CD3FC8]k^Am

kAm“(6 5:5?VE H2:E 7@C 7C665@>[” r2CE6C D2:5] “(6 7@F89E 7@C :E]”k^Am

kAmx? `h_a[ 2D r@?7656C2E6 >@?F>6?ED H6?E FA :? 7C@?E @7 ?62C=J 6G6CJ 4@FCE9@FD6 :? E96 DE2E6[ ':C8:?:2 6?24E65 2 4@?DE:EFE:@? E92E 5:D6?7C2?49:D65 q=24< G@E6CD] {J?49:?8 42D6D C@D6[ A62<:?8 2E >@C6 E92? `__ A6C J62C :? `ghf[ 2?5 zF z=FI z=2? 24E:G:EJ 3642>6 :?4C62D:?8=J 2446AE23=6[ C6DF=E:?8 :? 2 A2C256 E9C@F89 5@H?E@H? #:49>@?5 :? `had]k^Am

kAm%96 H2C @G6C >@?F>6?ED H2D 7@F89E G:4:@FD=J :? E96 >65:2[ |2CE:? D2:5] ~? E96 @?6 92?5[ ?6HDA2A6CD =:<6 E96 #:49>@?5 uC66 !C6DD 2?5 E96 s2:=J !=2?6E BF6DE:@?65 E96 >@?F>6?ED] ~? E96 @E96C 92?5[ E96 #:49>@?5 %:>6D\s:DA2E49 25G@42E65 7@C E96>]k^Am

kAm“xE H2D F?:7J:?8 7@C H9:E6 #:49>@?56CD[” ':52 D2:5] “qFE E96C6 H2D 2 DF3DE2?E:2= 8C@H:?8[ H62=E9:6C q=24< A@AF=2E:@? E92E H2D ?@E ~z H:E9 :E]”k^Am

kAm%96J H6C6 2=D@ F?:7J:?8 7@C 72C\2H2J 4@F?E:6D[ >2?J @7 H9@> 4@F?E65 E96:C @H? C6=2E:G6D 2>@?8 E96 >@C6 E92? ad_[___ r@?7656C2E6 5625] x? ':C8:?:2 q6249[ 2 af\7@@E E2== r@?7656C2E6 D@=5:6C H2D 6C64E65 :? `h_d 367@C6 2 4C@H5 @7 `[d__ @?=@@<6CD]k^Am

kAm“{@DE r2FD6” >@?F>6?E 3F:=5:?8 D:>>6C65 :? E96 =2E6C 92=7 @7 E96 46?EFCJ] %96?[ :? E96 `hh_D[ 2 ?6H H2G6 @7 3F:=5:?8 E@@< @77[ E9:D @?6 7F?565 3J =@42=:E:6D[ =68:D=2EFC6D 2?5 >FD6F>D E92E D@F89E E@ >6>@C:2=:K6 2 3C@256C 42DE @7 9:DE@C:42= 7:8FC6D]k^Am

kAm%9:D =2DE H2G6 D2H E96 4C62E:@? @7 >@?F>6?ED E@ q=24< #:49>@?5 E6??:D =686?5 pCE9FC pD96[ !C6D:56?E p3C292> {:?4@=? 2?5 3FD:?6DDH@>2? |288:6 {] (2=<6C]k^Am

kAmxE 2=D@ D2H >@C6 r@?7656C2E6 >@?F>6?ED[ :?4=F5:?8 E96 4@?DECF4E:@? @7 2 E@>3DE@?6 E@ 2 r@?7656C2E6 3C:8256 :? w6?C:4@ r@F?EJ :? `hhh[ 2 r@?7656C2E6 D@=5:6C >6>@C:2= :? uC656C:4<D3FC8 :? a__h[ 2?5 2?@E96C >6>@C:2= :? v:=6D r@F?EJ 2D C646?E=J 2D a_`d]k^Am

kAm%9:D >@C6 C646?E H2G6 @7 4@?DECF4E:@? 4@?E:?F6D E@ E9:D 52J] x? a_`h[ E96 ':C8:?:2 |FD6F> @7 u:?6 pCED 4@>>:DD:@?65 2 Sa >:==:@? DE2EF6 7C@> q=24< D4F=AE@C z69:?56 (:=6J] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^G>72]>FD6F>^23@FE^CF>@CD\@7\H2C^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm%96 DE2EF6[ “#F>@CD @7 (2C[” 56A:4ED 2 q=24< >2? 2DEC:56 2 32EE=6 9@CD6[ :? H92E E96 >FD6F> 56D4C:36D 2D 2 “5:C64E C6DA@?D6” E@ 2 DE2EF6 @7 y]t]q] $EF2CE @? |@?F>6?E pG6?F6]k^2mk^Am

kAm%96 DE2EF6 7246D E96 &?:E65 s2F89E6CD @7 E96 r@?7656C24J’D #:49>@?5 3FD:?6DD @77:46[ H9:49 :D AC:G2E6 AC@A6CEJ 2?5 DE:== 5:DA=2JD 2 r@?7656C2E6 @36=:D<]k^Am

kAmp?5 :? a_aa[ 2 >@?F>6?E E@ ':C8:?:2’D H@>6? 563FE65 @FED:56 E96 #:49>@?5 r2A:E@=] %96 AC@;64E[ 4@>>:DD:@?65 3J ':C8:?:2’D v6?6C2= pDD6>3=J :? a_`_[ :D 2=D@ 2 C6DA@?D6 E@ A2DE >@?F>6?ED[ H9:49 AC65@>:?2?E=J 762EFC65 >6?]k^Am

k9am!FD9:?8 324< 282:?DE H9:E6 DFAC6>24Jk^9am

kAm!FD9324< 282:?DE E96 >@?F>6?ED 2=D@ 82:?65 G@=F>6 :? a_`d :? E96 H2<6 @7 2 >2DD D9@@E:?8 :? r92C=6DE@?[ $@FE9 r2C@=:?2] %96 D9@@E6C[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^C:49>@?5]4@>^?6HD^?2E:@?2=^DFAC6>6\4@FCE\C6;64ED\2AA62=\7C@>\5J=2??\C@@7\H9@\<:==65\h^2CE:4=60hachf66c\_27h\d44b\gbce\d67_4hcf2fh6]9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmsJ=2?? #@@7[k^2m <:==65 ?:?6 q=24< A6@A=6 2E 2? p7C:42? |6E9@5:DE tA:D4@A2= r9FC49] #@@7[ 2 H9:E6 DFAC6>24:DE[ =2E6C 25>:EE65 E@ H2?E:?8 E@ DE2CE 2 4:G:= H2C] !9@E@D 6>6C865 @7 #@@7 H2G:?8 2 r@?7656C2E6 7=28]k^Am

kAm$9@CE=J 27E6C[ 2 !2EC:4< r@F?EJ ;F586 E@@< :E FA@? 9:>D6=7 E@ C6>@G6 2 A@CEC2:E @7 $EF2CE 7C@> 9:D 4@FCEC@@>[ H9:49 H2D 6G6? =@42E65 :? 2 E@H? — $EF2CE — ?2>65 27E6C E96 r@?7656C2E6 86?6C2=]k^Am

kAm“xE :D >J 8@2= — 2?5 >J 5FEJ 2D 2 ;F586 — E@ AC@G:56 2 EC:2= D6EE:?8 E92E :D A6C46:G65 3J 2== A2CE:4:A2?ED 2D 72:C[ ?6FEC2= 2?5 H:E9@FE D@ >F49 2D 2 9:?E @7 AC6;F5:46] r@?7656C2E6 DJ>3@=D 2C6[ D:>A=J AFE[ @776?D:G6 E@ p7C:42?\p>6C:42?D[ 2?5 E9:D C624E:@? :D 32D65 @? 724E 2?5 4=62C[ DEC2:89E7@CH2C5 9:DE@CJ[” HC@E6 yF586 |2CE:? u] r=2C<]k^Am

kAmx? a_`h[ s2G:D’ ?2>6 H2D DEC:AA65 7C@> E96 =2?5>2C< 2C49 2E u@CE |@?C@6 :? w2>AE@?] %96 C6>@G2= H2D 5@?6 2E E96 C6BF6DE @7 v@G] #2=A9 }@CE92> D9@CE=J 27E6C 8C25F2E6 D49@@= J62C3@@< A9@E@D 6>6C865 @7 9:> H62C:?8 3=24<7246[ 2 D42?52= E92E ?62C=J C6DF=E65 :? 9:D C6D:8?2E:@?]k^Am

kAmx? yF=J a_a_[ =@42= A9:=2?E9C@A:DE y@6 s2?:6= @776C65 Sd_[___ E@ C6>@G6 2 r@?7656C2E6 D@=5:6C >@?F>6?E 6C64E65 :? `h`` @? E96 rF=A6A6C r@F?EJ r@FCE9@FD6]k^Am

kAm$:>:=2C DE6AD 92G6 366? E2<6? 2E E96 ?2E:@?2= =6G6= :? E96 H2<6 @7 u=@J5VD 562E9] r@?8C6DD 4C62E65 2 4@>>:DD:@? E@ 42E2=@8 >:=:E2CJ :?DE2==2E:@?D[ D9:AD[ 2CEH@C< 2?5 @E96C :4@?D ?2>65 27E6C r@?7656C2E6 7:8FC6D]k^Am

kAm$:?46 E96?[ u@CE {66 :? !C:?46 v6@C86 r@F?EJ H2D C6?2>65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9@>6]2C>J]>:=^8C688252>D^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qmu@CE vC688\p52>Dk^2m 27E6C EH@ p7C:42? p>6C:42? @77:46CD] u@CE !:4<6EE ?62C q=24<DE@?6[ ?2>65 :? 9@?@C @7 v6?] v6@C86 !:4<6EE[ 3642>6 u@CE q2C7@@E :? 9@?@C @7 |652= @7 w@?@C C64:A:6?E r@=] '2? %] q2C7@@E]k^Am

kAm!6C92AD E96C6 :D ?@ 36EE6C DJ>3@= @7 E96 4@>A=6I 9:DE@CJ @7 E96 r:G:= (2C :? ':C8:?:2 E92? E96 DAC2H=:?8 pC=:?8E@? }2E:@?2= r6>6E6CJ[ E96 2?46DEC2= 9@>6 E@ {66 E92E D6CG65 2D &]$] pC>J 9625BF2CE6CD 5FC:?8 E96 r:G:= (2C] xE H2D 564:565 E@ EFC? E96 8C@F?5D :?E@ 2 46>6E6CJ E@ 8F2C2?E66 {66 H@F=5 ?@E 36 23=6 E@ =:G6 E96C6]k^Am

kAmx? `h__[ r@?8C6DD 2AAC@G65 2 A=2? E@ 2==@H r@?7656C2E6 C6>2:?D E@ 36 C6:?E6CC65 2E pC=:?8E@?[ 2?5 2 3C@?K6 >6>@C:2= H2D 6C64E65 :? `h`c] '2C:@FD AF3=:4 >66E:?8D 92G6 366? 96=5[ :?4=F5:?8 :? pF8FDE[ 23@FE H96C6 E@ >@G6 E96 DE2EF6]k^Am

kAmu=@J5’D 562E9 4@>A6==65 E9@D6 :? #:49>@?5 E@ >2<6 E96:C @H? DE2E6>6?ED @? :?6BF2=:EJ]k^Am

kAm~?6 @7 E9@D6 DE2E6>6?ED H2D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]C64=2:>:?8E96>@?F>6?E]4@>^Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<Qm#64=2:>:?8 %96 |@?F>6?Ek^2m[ 2 AC@E6DE 2CE AC@;64E 4C62E65 3J #:49>@?5 2CE:DED p=6I rC:BF: 2?5 sFDE:? z=6:? :? E96 H2<6 @7 u=@J5VD >FC56C]k^Am

kAm%92E DF>>6C[ E96 5F@ AC@;64E65 :>286D @7 u=@J5[ 2D H6== 2D 9:DE@C:42= q=24< 7:8FC6D =:<6 #@D2 !2C<D[ E96 #6G] |2CE:? {FE96C z:?8 yC] 2?5 x52 q] (6==D @? DECF4EFC6D 2?5 DEC66ED E9C@F89@FE #:49>@?5[ >@DE ?@E23=J @? E96 {66 >@?F>6?E]k^Am

kAm“x E9:?< E96 H2J AF3=:4 2CE 2?5 >@?F>6?E2=:EJ 92D 366? FD65 :? #:49>@?5 92D 366? 2 C62==J @?6\D:565 6?562G@C[ 2?5 :E 92D @7E6? @37FD42E65 2?5 5:DE@CE65 E96 24EF2= 9:DE@CJ @7 H92E 92D 92AA6?65 :? E9:D C68:@?[ :? @FC 4@F?ECJ[ :? @FC 4:EJ[” rC:BF: D2:5]k^Am

kAmp=D@ 5:DA=2J65 @? E96 {66 >@?F>6?E H2D 2? :>286 @7kDEC@?8m k^DEC@?8m|2C4FD\s2G:5 !6E6CD[ H9@ H2D D9@E 2?5 <:==65 :? a_`g 3J #:49>@?5 A@=:46 H9:=6 92G:?8 2 >6?E2= 962=E9 4C:D:D] x? a_a_[ AC@E6DE6CD E@@< @G6C E96 {66 r:C4=6 2?5 :?7@C>2==J ?2>65 :E |2C4FD\s2G:5 !6E6CD r:C4=6]k^Am

kAmu@==@H:?8 E96 C6>@G2= @7 E96 {66 DE2EF6[ DE2E6 @77:4:2=D A=2465 2 76?46 2C@F?5 E96 4:C4=6 :? y2?F2CJ a_a`] p =2?5D42A:?8 A=2? H2D 2AAC@G65 3J E96 4:EJ 56DA:E6 rC:BF:[ z=6:? 2?5 @E96CD 25G@42E:?8 7@C 2 4@>>F?:EJ 82C56? 2E E96 4:C4=6]k^Am

kAm“x7 J@F =@@< 2E E96 >@?F>6?ED E96>D6=G6D[ E96J H6C6 AFE :? A=246 3J A6@A=6 :? A@H6C 7@C A@=:E:42= 286?52D[ 7:?2?4:2= 286?52D[ 2?5 :E E@@< FD `b_ J62CD E@ 4@CC64E E9@D6 >:DE2<6D[” rC:BF: D2:5] “$@ x’5 =:<6 E@ D66 2 7FEFC6 7@C E92E DA246 H9:49 5@6D?’E C6A62E E9@D6 >:DE2<6D[ 2?5 :D 3F:=E FA@? 5:2=@8F6 2?5 4@>>F?:EJ :?E6C24E:@?]”k^Am

k9am#6>:?56CD C6>2:?k^9am

kAm%96C6’D 2=D@ 366? C6D:DE2?46 282:?DE C6>@G:?8 E96 >@?F>6?ED]k^Am

kAmx? a_`f[ :? E96 H2<6 @7 E96 r92C=@EE6DG:==6 42D6[ 2 AC@\r@?7656C2E6 C2==J H2D 96=5 @? |@?F>6?E pG6?F6] p 8C@FA @7 23@FE D6G6? A6@A=6 96=5 r@?7656C2E6 7=28D 2?5 2C8F65 H:E9 2 4C@H5 @7 4@F?E6CAC@E6DE6CD]k^Am

kAmx? a_a`[ 7@C>6C #6AF3=:42? {E] v@G] q:== q@==:?8 H2D @?6 @7 E96 AC@>:?6?E G@:46D :? DFAA@CE @7 AFEE:?8 E96 DE2EF6D :? 4@?E6IE[ C2E96C E92? E62C:?8 E96> 5@H?]k^Am

kAm“(96? J@F 4@>>6?46 2 AFC86 @7 9:DE@C:42= 7:8FC6D[ ?2>6D[ 6E4] 7C@> E96 AF3=:4 DBF2C6[ :E :D 92C5 E@ DE@A :E[” 96 D2:5 :? 2 |2C49 a_a` D@4:2= >65:2 A@DE]k^Am

kAmWq@==:?8 5:5 ?@E C6DA@?5 E@ 2? :?E6CG:6H C6BF6DE 7@C E9:D DE@CJ]Xk^Am

kAmpD C646?E=J 2D s646>36C[ E96 |2E96HD r@F?EJ q@2C5 >@G65 E@ 5665 AF3=:4 =2?5 F?56C 2 r@?7656C2E6 DE2EF6 @? E96 9:DE@C:4 4@FCE9@FD6 8C@F?5D E@ 2 AC:G2E6 AC6D6CG2E:@? 8C@FA E@ 6?DFC6 :E H@F=5 ?@E 36 C6>@G65]k^Am

kAm%@52J[ 9F?5C65D @7 E96 C6>2:?:?8 r@?7656C2E6 DJ>3@=D E9C@F89@FE E96 4@>>@?H62=E9 2C6 =6DD @G6CE — =:<6 E96 DEC66ED 2?5 9:89H2JD DE:== ?2>65 27E6C r@?7656C2E6 96C@6D]k^Am

kAm|@?:42 wFE49:?D@?[ AC6D:56?E @7 E96 w6?C:4@ }ppr![ ?@E65 E96 y63 $EF2CE !2C<H2J :? v=6? p==6?j }@CE9 2?5 $@FE9 r@?7656C2E6 2G6?F6D :? $2?5DE@?j 2?5 G2C:@FD {66 2G6?F6D DAC625 24C@DD E96 C68:@?[ 2D DJ>3@=D E92E 2C6 @7E6? @G6C=@@<65]k^Am

kAm“%96 >@?F>6?ED 2C6 @?6 E9:?8 3642FD6 E96J H6C6 9F86[” wFE49:?D@? D2:5] “qFE D@>6E9:?8 =:<6 2 DEC66E ?2>6 @C 2? 2C62 :D D@ :?8C2:?65 :? 6G6CJ52J =:76j x 5@?’E E9:?< :E’D 2=H2JD 4@??64E65 E92E E96D6 2C6 ?2>65 27E6C r@?7656C2E6 D@=5:6CD @C 9@?@C:?8 E96 r@?7656C24J]”k^Am

kAm~?6 DF886DE:@? 7C@> wFE49:?D@? :?G@=G6D C6A=24:?8 r@?7656C2E6 ?2>6D H:E9 ?2>6D @7 E9@D6 H9@ H@C<65 E@ C646:G6 6BF2= C:89ED DF49 2D 4:G:= C:89ED =6256C u2??:6 {@F w2>6C]k^Am

kAmwFE49:?D@? D2:5 E96 36DE H2J E@ 9@?@C E9@D6 H9@ 7@F89E 7@C 6BF2=:EJ :? AC6G:@FD 86?6C2E:@?D :D E@ 7:89E 7@C =2DE:?8 492?86 2?5 ?@E D@=6=J 492?86 2 DE2EF6 @C 2 ?2>6]k^Am

kAm“(92E :D 6G6? >@C6 :>A@CE2?E E92? ;FDE C6>@G:?8 @C C6?2>:?8 E96D6 DJ>3@=D :D 6?DFC:?8 E92E E96 H@C< :D 36:?8 5@?6 E@ 255C6DD E96 DJDE6>2E:4 32D:D @7 H9J E96J H6C6 FA :? E96 7:CDE A=246[ 2?5 E96 C@@E @7 2 =@E @7 E96D6 DJDE6>:4 :DDF6D E92E DE:== A=28F6 E96 q=24< 4@>>F?:EJ 2?5 @E96C 4@>>F?:E:6D @7 4@=@C 2?5 @E96C >2C8:?2=:K65 4@>>F?:E:6D[” D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmpD 7@C #:49>@?5VD C6>@G65 >@?F>6?ED[ D@>6 @7 E96> C6D:56 2E E96 q=24< w:DE@CJ |FD6F> 2?5 rF=EFC2= r6?E6C @7 ':C8:?:2 27E6C E96 4:EJ 8C2?E65 E96> @H?6CD9:A] %96 qw|'p 92D E6>A@C2C:=J =@2?65 >@?F>6?ED E@ %96 '2=6?E:?6 2?5 E96 |FD6F> @7 r@?E6>A@C2CJ pCE :? {@D p?86=6D H:E9:? E96 =2DE J62C]k^Am

kAmq@E9 E96 qw|'p 2?5 %96 '2=6?E:?6 92G6 4@?5F4E65 DFCG6JD 2D<:?8 E96 AF3=:4 23@FE :ED 766=:?8D @? E96 {@DE r2FD6 2?5 E96 r@?7656C2E6 >@?F>6?ED]k^Am

kAm%@52J[ %96 '2=6?E:?6 DE:== 3C:?8D :? G:D:E@CD — >2?J H9@ H6C6 23=6 E@ D66 E96 DE2EF6 @7 s2G:D :? :ED ?6H6DE C6?5:E:@?i 9@C:K@?E2=[ DA=2EE6C65 :? 8C277:E:[ =J:?8 2D :E H2D E96 52J AC@E6DE6CD AF==65 :E 5@H?]k^Am